I am Ishpreet kaur
- Nov 13, 2022
Sat Sri Brothers and Sister,
I have one question which has been on my mind for many-many years and for which I am until today unable to find a satisfactory answer. This question can be summarize as "Does God control everything in the Universe?" Allow me to explain myself...
In the Guru Granth Sahib, there appears countless times verses stating to the effect that :- "God is in charge and controls everything in the Universe. That nothing happens which is outside the Will of God. That God is the doer of all. That literally God IS All." These are not exact verses from the Granth Sahib but rather my understanding of verses. I do not think it would be necessary to quote any verses from the Granth Sahib as anyone reading it will bound to find countless verses stating to the effect.
The problem I find is elsewhere the Granth Sahib (and many other holy scriptures) also state that: "Man is responsible for his actions. That Man has free will and can and should decide what is right and wrong."
My dear brothers and sisters, I am confused! To my thinking both statements are contradictory. If God is the controller and doer of all, how can Man have free will? If man has free will, then how can God be said to control and do EVERYTHING? If free will is within the Will of God, how can we say it is FREE?
If free will is an illusion, then why does God punish Man by sending him to hell or reward him by sending him to heaven? What need be there for a heaven or hell if all that man does is according to His Will?
I am utterly confused and puzzled by this enigma! I have searched for an answer in many books and scriptures but the answer eludes me. I have searched through this website and found only ONE thread discussing free will. Kudos to Etinder for his lengthily exposition on free will. While I found his discussion very enlightening on the topic of free will, it still did not resolve my conflict. This is because Etinder choose to discuss free will from the philosophical point of view, leaving God out of the question. What I need is an explanation from Gurbani i.e. a theological or religious point of view.
If there be among you an enlightened one who can solve this mystery for me I shall forever be great full to him or her.
Thank you in advance.
Guru Ki Fateh
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa waheguru ji ki fatehNothing is as cleverer as the human beings on this planet earth .
The Human beings are the only cleverer creatures , who even don't spare GOD in their cleverer tricks to survival .
GOD is just used as the scapegoat by human beings their survival and fulfillment of their desires .
Those who talk about sin , bad ,evil even they know that nothing sort of that thing exists ,
The desire of one human being is a sin for another human being .
All over the world , religions are only made for this :
"I can do all the things , If you do any of these things what I do , You have committed a crime , sin , evil"
Each and every human being follows the above line whether directly or indirectly .
Even if there is .001 truth in this world , then that truth is the fodder for justification for those commit falsehood and tell lie.
For example:- if we have to stand on one leg we have two options to either stand on left or right. This is human's will. To either choose good or bad deeds. But we can't put our both legs in air it's our limitation. Either you did good or bad power of doing work comes from God only. If we did good we get good results and vice versa so everything is in hukam of God and to decide what to do God gives us understanding and mind like if we procastinate we fail its hukam of God. Hukam means niyam or rules.
Hope you understand or hope I m right in this understanding