Are those people Who committed crimes against innocent sikh 1984 less than wazir khan's war crimes?
The Guru lived in a time of war when the law of the sword ruled supreme.
Upon toppling Wazir Khan, the Guru established the first Sikh state. This was the way of the world.
What do you propose as a modern means of delivering punishment? And what do you think will be the consequence of the intricate web of power that protects these evildoers in the first place? If you try enacting Old World solutions, I can guarantee you a lot more innocent people will die in the interim.
This isn't the same as the situation under Aurangzeb, who was a fascist dictator. We live in a democracy. Even if it is held together by glue and sticky tape.
The fact is Guru gobind singh ji encouraged Khalsa not only to punish Wazir Khan but also capture political power.This was the foundation of Khalsa movement and 70 -80 year later this lead to estabishment to Khalsa Raj.
Yes, I said this above. I also said that it was a different world back then.
What I mean was these days almost every sikh just pick a saakhi,Baani and try to justify his/her own personal beleif
I see it happen every day. But it's all God's will in the end.
CBI giving clean chit to tytler has shown the world that what he is doing behind the scenes
I'm sure he has his reasons.
The reason I mentioned Rao because Rao is now completely disowned by congress.All the bad things that happened in 80s and early 90s are blamed on him.He was blamed for delaying army in 1984,demolition babri masjid and even the escape of anderson in 1984
the congress itself distnaced itself from all the crimes committed by party.One can wonder is the future waiting foir manmohan singh ?all the bad things that are happening these days will be blamed on him
Doubtful.
Moderates and progressives seem to love him. His re-election is proof of his popularity.
Max it looks to me I am discussing this matter with a congress spokesperson rather than a person who independently study Indian politics.
I could just as easily say you sound like an Akali or one of those Sikhs who has allied himself with fascists like the BJP. But I won't.
Do you even think that Sonia entered politics for sake of doing good for people of India? The reallity is she entered so Future of her children is secured in Indian politics.She very well know that her Italian origin will always haunt her and may be coalition Partner use this to dump her so She chooses a man who was the least threat to Nehru Gandhi Dynasty and There was no better person than manmohan singh to do this.In a team if top player refuses captainship then it goes to second best,Manmohan singh was not even in the list of second best leaders of congress.
Dynasties are a part of Indian politics. One of the consequence of a family-oriented society is that it inevitably results in mafioso power play. Sending buckets of gold to your local politician in the hope that, one day, they will be able to do something for you when the time comes is part of our flawed system because it is a part of our flawed society.
But that isn't a slight against Manmohan Singh's efforts to make India a better place. Nor against Sonia Ghandi and her family for that matter.
India's economy was growing before Manmohan singh Infact econmy of many asian countries are growing,There is hardly any report Manmohan singh's steps has reduced poverty in India.As far as education bill is concerned that is just a paper bill with no proper infrastructure ro implement
India's economy was beginning to grow, but Manmohan Singh's government ensured that India's internal market was kept strong and able to function independently of foreign trade. China failed to do this its government felt the impact of the economic crisis -- the only reason they're still standing is because of their reserves of American currency. Though there are suggestions that their continuing failure to ignite a stable internal market will be their downfall in the future.
Manmohan Singh has put systems in place to ensure this can never happen to India.
And as India's economy grows and as the youth move into positions of influence, the infrastructure to support the new education bill will gradually click into place.
Such radical reforms rarely happen overnight. Unless you're China.
No one is saying that he can single handedly uproot the corruption but he should ensure that the corruption should be decreased ,but the fact is corruption has increased.
And the fact that we're talking about those corrupt individuals means these people are being caught out one by one by the media, executive enforcement, and the judiciary.
If Manmohan Singh had a mantra for his
modus operandi, it would probably be: "Don't use cannon to kill mosquito."
When you squeeze the beast's throat, it spits and spurts and struggles for air. But eventually, it passes out and dies. Manmohan Singh has set up the intricate dance of dominos and is watching quietly as they all fall into their rightful places.
Manmohan Singh is the guy who sees ten moves ahead while the rest of us can barely figure out the next move.
Let me tell you as a middle class man from last 2 years the food price inflation has hurted us the most.I don't even understand where the food has gone ,what wrong policies govt has implemented so that food prices are touching sky high.At first they said that it is an international crisis but later on price of food items went down in international market ,but no such thing happened in India.
I'm not an economist, so I can't explain this phenomenon.
----
Anyway, it's been nice talking with you. You seem like a very mature and well-meaning person, so I know you will understand when I don't respond to future posts. I foresee a 21 page quote-a-thon if one of us doesn't bow out now, so I'll take that as my cue.
All the best.
