It is for no Sikh to decide about that. SGGS, is our only Guru. Period.
Ishna ji perhaps the following may be of help,Many thanks to Prakash ji for pointing out that Naam(u) and GuR Jot are noticeably absent from it.
With the above perhaps it is worthwhile re-checking what is, if anything missing. I have not studied Jaap Sahib to comment.For example:
Naam(u) or GuR Jot, chosen decision criteria of Prakash.S.Bagga ji are not mentioned by Sheikh/Baba Farid's compositions in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. Our Guru ji though decided to have it as part of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji.
Lesson: Sometimes we are too wise for own goodpeacesign
Ishna Bhain ji you have brilliantly handled your posts. There is absolutely nothing wrong in asking such question.I'm not trying to act like a 'Guru' or to judge Gurbani (since Jaap is not Gurbani). Apologies if I'm coming across that way.
I know I understand about 2% of Gurmat thinking so I thought I'd check with others what they thought about Jaap.
Is it hubris to ask such a question?