How can any one have prof when there is nothing has been said about naam. You show me where any guru told you or any one to do the simran of particular naam, shabad. I can not find any where in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji that any guru gave us the mantar to do the simran.
When BHATS said wah guru they meant to praise the guru of that time. They were not praising the God. After the Khalsa was created many Sikhs started praising Gobind Singh and thats when they said wahe-guru. But when Gobibd Singh created Khalsa he sait is was Akal's foj. He did not say wahegur's foj.
The Akal was used by Hargobind when he created Akal Takhat.
Reciting of naam is Hindu tradition. Nanag was born Hindu and he went to many of Hindu holy places and talked with many sadhu n yogis. All his thinking was based on Hinduism. He was very logical person. He try to show people the there is no need to do any KARM_KAND to live good life.
We now doing opposite to what Nanak said. It is shame that we can not understand what he wanted us to learn.
No Sikh wrote Sikh history. It was written by mostly Hindus and maybe 2-3 Muslim. The Hindus made all the gurus KARAMATI. We are still syaing that Guru will help us when ever there is tuff time. No Guru can help us. If it be possible then when Hindus worshiping shivling and other stone, then Hindus be saved too. We create our own problem only we can fix them.
So how can I believe wahegur as as God? that was the question asked. I am sorry if I am going out of the way
Maybe the SPN just looking for YES or NO?
Sat Sri Akaal,
One's own mind is the biggest hurdle, negativity of mind is the hurdle,
Learned people have different understanding, what about millions of people
who are not learned, are also part of religion. In fact daily routines are followed by that section of religious society.
religion is opium for masses not for individuals.
After getting a medical degree, one just don't treat learned, treat everyone.
but try to explain disease cause prevention cause of giving pill etc to unlearned, try what happens next,
Just give a simple pill from your awareness, that's what dera's baba's are doing
Poor are there in dera's, with babas for pill and learned for marketing and commercial.
Before taking pill learned asks so many questions, unlearned just have it.
Naam simran is recomended in Guru Granth Sahib Ji,
perspective of NAAM if different for learned and ignorant.
One is reflected through action, (karam) which is performed by body unconsciously and subconsciously,
not
what one say consciously
Consciousness to penetrate depths of subconscious and unconscious mind
takes years and sometimes generations
and a few time a moment with blessing of NATURE. for body to perform.
and
there is union of unconscious and conscious mind, or one performs
action with complete mind.
So Gurubani is in RAGA's for repeated vocal penetration to wake up unconscious mind
but not just what we say or preach consciously.
but perspective for learned is different and ignorant is different.
though pill is same, but perception of having pill is different.
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa
Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
put the same sticks into the hands of someone that has a passion, a love and focus for playing the drums...and you have something completely different.
