inder preet
SPNer
- Jun 11, 2013
- 39
- 29
- 44
Can anyone answer me why guru ANgad dev ji asked.for janam patri of guru NAnak dev ji.and if i can get details of this saakhi i will be very thankful to you.
Inderpreet Ji
Why would Guru Angad Dev Ji ask janampatri of Guru Nanak Dev Ji?
Guru Nanak Ji rejected all such rituals ,Janehoo etc and many superstitions
do you think his successor Guru Angad Dev Ji the second Guru would ask Janampatri of guru nanak dev ji?
I have read this sakhi in sab toh vaddi bhai baale vali.janam sakhi which i have purchased from amritsar golden temple (sri harmandar sahib).thats why i want to know that if it is written in any sakhi and it is been sold in amritsar then there might be some reality in it that is why i want to know the truth that whether it is fake or true.
inder preet ji
The gold standard for testing stories about the Gurus are the Vaaran of Bhai Gurdas. The story of Guru Amardas ji starts about here
http://www.searchgurbani.com/bhai_gu...auri/46/line/5
Press the link and then keep on reading until you get to Guru Ram Das.
There are many sakhis -- some more reliable than others -- some are matched to the vaaran -- but all of them embellish with additional details. No two collections of sakhis match up perfectly, although all are claimed to be true. That raises suspicions. (Luckysingh ji's reaction is a good example of that.) When add-ons are spotted your next step is to see if it is confirmed in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji itself. If NO, then you need to compare the detail to common sense. (arshdeep ji's reply is a good example of common sense) If NO again, then you are reading creative writing and need to be wary.