• Welcome to all New Sikh Philosophy Network Forums!
    Explore Sikh Sikhi Sikhism...
    Sign up Log in

Vienna Clash May Put Caste In Global Spotlight

Jan 6, 2005
Metro-Vancouver, B.C., Canada
Vienna clash may put caste in global spotlight

26 May 2009, 0420 hrs IST, Subodh Ghildiyal, TNN

NEW DELHI: Caste fingerprints on the sensational Vienna shootout among Sikhs could result in renewed international pressure for recognition of caste-based discrimination as a global concern, with many hinting at a revived clamour for treating casteism as racism.

The ghost of Durban conference in 2001, where India fought back a determined and coordinated bid by NGOs to recognise casteism as racism, may raise its head again. Only this month, Indian government is said to have rebuffed a fresh offensive from Scandinavian countries underlining their stand on caste-race parity.

The move came in the run-up to two-day review of Durban racism conference last month, taking India by surprise. The Indian stand on the controversial issue has been that while caste system is a form of discrimination, it could not be equated with racism. It has cited its constitutional commitment against casteism as proof of its credentials.

But dalit lobbies say that Vienna bloodshed has blown holes in the argument that caste was an Indian phenomenon, firmly showing that it had spilled out on global platform along with the diaspora. Says Vivek Kumar, who teaches sociology in JNU, "Caste has moved beyond India with Indian diaspora as the latter does not move as individuals but takes its cultural baggage along. There is growing evidence that caste is showing its face in other countries."

Dalit groups concede that not much may change on the issue immediately as Indian voice is influential in global fora. But, they add, growing evidence of presence of caste on global platforms, like incidents in Vienna, would put pressure on India. "We will raise the issue through NGOs across the world," said Ashok Bharti, who runs National Conference of Dalit Organisations.

The intra-Sikh violence is reported to be a perennial point of conflict as Ravidasi Sikhs have floated their own gurudwaras, attracting hostility from upper caste Sikhs. The hotbed is Europe, Canada and UK. The problem could be serious in future owing to sheer numbers. An estimate puts Sikh population in UK between four to five lakh, of which one-third are said to be dalits.

Sources said caste was getting recognition as an issue outside India. There is a strong demand from sections of dalit diaspora in UK, Canada and US that governments enact laws to deal with caste-related crimes as with race-related crimes. These are countries with huge Indian-origin population, including Sikhs. In UK, Caste Watch has been formed to detail cases of caste-related crimes.

For India, the pressure from Vienna could be serious in the wake of post-Durban Conference pressure that casteism falls in the category of work and descent and was akin to racism. Massive pressure from NGOs in Durban Conference on Racism in 2001 was resisted by India. However, the UN Council on Human Rights appointed special rapporteurs to report on caste discrimination in India.

Aug 27, 2005
Baltimore Md USA
It will be interesting to see how the UK handles this problem. They most certainly have a unwritten social class issue. The Royals is just the tip of it.
In reference to India I think the caste system is abhorant. To condemn someone merely because of thier lineage is wrong. I can understand the varna system where everyone had aparticular duty to the community determined by their talents but it was *******ed when they highest members of the community wanted to pass on their virtues simply by birth and thus have a ruling class that one had to be born into. I also think a misunderstanding of or using karma as a decider. For example a person born into poverty is the result of karma so society believes he was a horible person in past lives so he must be horible. I guess what makes it bearible is the hope of a better station in life in the next life.



Jun 12, 2006
dalsingh ji

This does look to be more about the politics of caste and less about the politics of religion.

Go to Panjab and you'll see how these two things are getting more and more fused.


Despite it many flaws, the UK class system doesn't openly tolerate violence between high and low class and there is a chance (albeit slim!) for upward mobility that doesn't exist in the Indian/Panjabi system.



📌 For all latest updates, follow the Official Sikh Philosophy Network Whatsapp Channel: