Sakhis - The Magic Of Sakhis - Share Your Views | Sikh Philosophy Network
  • Welcome to all New Sikh Philosophy Network Forums!
    Explore Sikh Sikhi Sikhism...
    Sign up Log in

Sakhis The Magic Of Sakhis - Share Your Views


Jun 1, 2004
The Magic of Saakhis by RUBIN PAUL SINGH

I have always loved listening to saakhis.

All kinds ... from stories about the Guru's childhood and their travels, to the tales of courage and bravery of the Khalsa on the battlefield - there is nothing I loved more than to be transported to the era of my Gurus and the heroes of our faith.

Whether it was at home, the Khalsa School, or Gurmat camp, I would take every opportunity I could to listen to a saakhi about Sikh history ... my history.

Much of that enthusiasm carried through my childhood, but as an adolescent, I started listening with a more critical ear. I remember once at camp, a teacher shared with us the story of Vaisakhi.

I'd heard the story hundreds of times, but it was one my favourites, so I listened attentively. As he told us about the Guru's call to the crowd that day and finally one man standing and offering his head, he said that Guru Sahib then "brought him in to an enclosed tent and returned minutes later with a sword dripping in blood."

Wait! ...What? Sword dripping in blood? Where did this come from? I immediately raised my hand, and the instructor explained that Guru Sahib had slaughtered a goat behind the tent. I never heard this before. Why would Guru Sahib need to fool the crowd in this way? Weren't they shocked enough that he was asking for a head in the first place? Why did this saakhi have to be unnecessarily embellished? I wondered how many other different "versions" of the saakhi were out there.

After much debate on this saakhi with the instructor and friends, I started re-thinking many of the saakhis I grew up with. Unlike gurbani, many of these stories have been passed down generations through oral tradition and have only recently been documented in the last hundred or so years, so how do we know what is fact and what is fiction?

Especially those that border the realm of logic ... the ones I was always amazed by. Did Baba Deep Singh really fight in battle with his head in his hand? In Mecca, did the Kaaba really move to the direction of Guru Nanak's feet?

I remember a student asking me at Gurmat camp once why Guru Nanak stopped a boulder with his bare hand if the Gurus were averse to using "magical powers."

Although I started to doubt many of the saakhis I grew up with, it did not shake my faith. In fact, what inspired me most of the Guru's lives were some of their worldly accomplishments - they were artists, poets, soldiers, human rights activists, environmentalists, city planners, architects, businessmen - all while living a productive family life.

The fact that Guru Sahib took a stand against the caste system at age 9 by refusing to wear the Hindu janeeo ... this is what amazes me! The fact my Guru directly challenged oppressors like Babar during his brutal invasion and called him out as a tyrant ... this to me is the magic of Guru Nanak!
Furthermore, some of these "super-hero" like saakhis that defy reality can be harmful too. Why would we want to make the Gurus larger than life and further distance ourselves from them? Maybe this is why people have resorted to babas and other intermediaries because we have made the Guru so "off-limits." After much thought on this, I stayed away from these "questionable" saakhis at camps and retreats and focused on those that were more logical or could be supported through bani.

Many years have passed and as I've started telling saakhis to my own children, I find myself with a dilemma. Part of me wants to tell the same stories I was told as a kid, so I can see their eyes light up in enthusiasm and amazement, the same way mine did ... even if the stories are a bit exaggerated.

Although I've decided to share only those saakhis that seem more realistic and practical, I still tend to "leave a little room." As I've discovered on my journey of Sikhi, the more I learn, the more I realize I don't know. The fact of the matter is, I wasn't there when Guru Sahib squeezed milk from Bhai Laalo's bread and blood from Malik Bhago's. I wasn't there when he stopped the boulder with his hand. I wasn't there when Guru Sahib asked that his feet be moved away from the direction of the Kaaba ... so perhaps I shouldn't let my parameters of logic restrict my understanding of history.
Maybe through simran, further reflection, and learning ... my parameters will also change.

We come from a rich and proud history. And as we individually connect with the events through our story-telling tradition, there is likely to be variation in the ways our stories are told. What is more important is that we are able to extract the central message - whether it is equality, truth, justice, or compassion.

I hope that saakhis continue to inspire generations to come and the eyes of Sikh children (and adults) continue to light up with these tales of compassion, courage and heroism.

Because when a saakhi from our history is conveyed with enthusiasm, emotion, and love ... it is nothing short of magic!


1947-2014 (Archived)
Jun 17, 2004
Yes :happy:
what inspired me most of the Guru's lives were some of their worldly accomplishments - they were artists, poets, soldiers, human rights activists, environmentalists, city planners, architects, businessmen - all while living a productive family life.

Some of the sakhis are not untrue, and many contain a moral truth told with the power of fable.

Anyway I myself love sakhis.
Feb 19, 2007
Delhi India
Narayanjot ji,

I am attaching an article "Baba Nanak in Iraq" which appeared in The Hindustan Times more than a year back. Now this is realistic and believable Sakhi.

Persons like Guru Nanak ji, Guru Gobind Singh ji, Baba Deep Singh Ji were highly magnetic personalities who had a bewitching effect on the beholder. The story clearly tells us that the bewitching effect of Baba Nanak's personality prevented the persons gathered, from stoning him and Mardana.

Is it not plausible that the same effect could have worked in the various Sakhis?

For example in Mecca when Guruji told the Maulvi to place his feet in the direction were God was not there, the Maulvi would have been so dazzled by Guruji's peronality that he might have imagined that the Kaaba had actually moved!

Similarly when Wali Khandari was creating a ruckus about rolling the rock down, Guruji might have given him a loving look and casually put his palm on the rock. This could have completely immobilised Wali. Both he and Mardana could have imagined that Guruji had actually stopped the rock from rolling.

It is a established fact that persons having powerful personae do play with the imaginations to create visions which the viewer believes to be real. This is not hypnotism since hypnotism can be learnt. This something much higher than that.


Create an account or login to comment

You must be a member in order to leave a comment

Create account

Create an account on our community. It's easy!

Log in

Already have an account? Log in here.

Shabad Vichaar by SPN'ers

istock_000003997254xsmall~s600x600.jpgThis week I took inspiration from the SPN jukebox. Literal English translation by Sant Singh Khalsa in black, my understanding in green underneath...

SPN on Facebook