• Welcome to all New Sikh Philosophy Network Forums!
    Explore Sikh Sikhi Sikhism...
    Sign up Log in

Sikh News Sikh Family Loses Court Battle


Jun 1, 2004
KUALA LUMPUR, Malaysia (AP) — A Sikh family lost a court battle Monday in Muslim-majority Malaysia for the right to cremate one of their relatives after officials said the man had converted to Islam years before his death.

The case threatens to revive complaints among non-Muslims that their religious rights are being sidelined — a grievance that has sparked interfaith tensions and severely eroded minority support for the government.

The family of Mohan Singh has been fighting Islamic authorities for custody of his body after Mohan, 41, died of a heart attack on May 25.

Officials from the Islamic government department of central Selangor state insisted Mohan converted to Islam in 1992, but the family said he practiced the Sikh religion until his death.

Malaysia's secular High Court ruled Monday that it had no jurisdiction in the case, saying that the matter of Mohan's conversion to Islam had already been decided by the Islamic Shariah court, said the family's lawyer, Rajesh Kumar.

Islamic authorities were expected to bury the body later Monday according to Muslim rites, since the Shariah court had already declared Mohan as a Muslim last month, Rajesh said.

Malaysia has a double-tier court system for civil matters — Muslims go to the Shariah court; non-Muslims go to secular courts. But in interfaith disputes, non-Muslims complain they lose out as Shariah courts get the final say and rarely rule in their favor.

The government has pledged to tackle legal ambiguities related to religious conversions. Authorities recently said minors can no longer be converted without both parents' consent, but the decision has not been made legally binding.

Officials have not announced any new proposals to resolve disputed conversions in cases where someone has died.

Ethnic Malay Muslims comprise nearly two-thirds of Malaysia's 28 million people. Minorities include ethnic Chinese and Indians who are mainly Buddhists, Christians, Hindus and Sikhs.
May 23, 2009
GYani Ji, I completely concur with you .Reminds me of the conversation Guru Nanak had with Bhai Mardana just before Mardana,s impending demise.To a question as to how Mardana ji,s mortal remains be disposed of:Would he want it to be thrown in a river as the brahmins do or be cremeated like a khashtri or be thrown to the elements like a vaishya,s or be buried as the shudras do,Mardana ji replied that by being in the Guru,s company and listening to Gur Updesh,thoughts of the disposal of his mortal remains never crossed his mind.
Guru Nanak then said that he felt that he should erect a Samadh so that Mardana ,s fame spreads everywhere and to this Mardana replies; Baba,it,s with great difficulty that I am escaping the Samadh of this body
and now you want me to be incarcerated in a samadh made with stone.The Guru was pleased with Mardana Ji,s answer and said Mardana, You have now realised Braham.
Humbly, Satnam Singh Randhawa

Gyani Jarnail Singh

Sawa lakh se EK larraoan
Jul 4, 2004
Beautifully put Satnam Singh Ji...couldnt have given a better suited example.
Bhai mardana ji had the unique love realtionship with Guru Ji..that when he died Guru Ji penned the slok addressed to him..Tuutee taand rebaba ki...OH the "String" of the rebaba has broken..the same Rebaba that accompanied the Arrival of Rabbee bani ..Mardaniag chherr rebeb nu..Bani aiyee ah..!!!
Thnaks for this
📌 For all latest updates, follow the Official Sikh Philosophy Network Whatsapp Channel: