• Welcome to all New Sikh Philosophy Network Forums!
    Explore Sikh Sikhi Sikhism...
    Sign up Log in

Recent content by valour

  1. V

    Sects Rada Swami Dera

    Sadh Sangat Ji, Do post any instances or statements derogatory to the Guru Granth Sahib Ji Mahraj by Radha Soami Preachers or Guru ? I wish to figure out the cause of opposition within the sikh masses. Is it true or fabricated ?
  2. V

    History Did The Punjabi Suba Movement Do Any Good To Punjab Or Sikhs ?

    Ambarsaria Ji, Why was the Punjabi suba movement initiated, as to what explanation was given by sikh leaders to motivate people towards it. Was it development or some other stunt ?
  3. V

    History Master Tara Singh (in Punjabi)

    Gyani Ji, As your profile shows, you are an elderly person. With due respect, I am not waiting in queue to hear your reply, and Infact, I have not asked for your reply here. you may, only if you like. My priority is that being still involved in my job, I am able to devote some time to think...
  4. V

    History Master Tara Singh (in Punjabi)

    SPNAdmin Ji, It would be great if you could write your "LONG" replies, without waiting for other members to respond. Dont hold your thoughts on the subject. Length of content does not matter if it is really informative. This is a period where we as a kaum have to introspect and analyze our past...
  5. V

    History Master Tara Singh (in Punjabi)

    SPNADMIN ji, The above mentioned achievements seem more like a theory in a course text book which is always obscure and concrete. Please cite a few examples, like institutions build up, any fruitful negotiation made. Some say he was a Bhola kind of person and didn't knew intricacies of...
  6. V

    History Did The Punjabi Suba Movement Do Any Good To Punjab Or Sikhs ?

    Kairon was a visionary. Those who have long beards have achieved nothing for ourselves. Much of our grief is due to their selfishness, short-sightedness and personal ambitions. Is this not the concept of brahmanism in sikhism, in principle ? Brahmins had janeu and exploited the poor and...
  7. V

    History Have We Been Critical Of Our Singhs Who Fought During The Turbulent Times Of 80s-90s ?

    Gyani Ji, Satnaam is the word I chant, and sometime i use Sat Sri AKAL to greet. and I done know what could be the answer to "why not" ? "why not" could be used if I was denigrating the other salutations. If you have any apprehensions which prompted to ask "Why not", then please...
  8. V

    History Have We Been Critical Of Our Singhs Who Fought During The Turbulent Times Of 80s-90s ?

    Satnaam Ji. Martyrs of a kaum shape the thought process of a kaum in general. Their life inspires some. But the important fact is that any act done by one in the context of Religion cannot be isolated from the adherents of the religion. Actions of one does influence the other. In...
  9. V

    History Master Tara Singh (in Punjabi)

    SO this means that he has been the great leader that Sikh kaum is indebted to. I guess, much of sikh youth hasn't read about the blunders he caused to the Kaum and he would be added to the black list of selfish, deceitful Akalis.
  10. V

    Sects Are Radha-Soamis Anti-Sikh?

    Thanks Ambarsaria Ji. I think there people around the head of such spiritual organizations or even the heads (after the institution has been running for long time) would always succumb to allure of Maya. These might well be true and the current Guru might not match the...
  11. V

    Sects Are Radha-Soamis Anti-Sikh?

    Satnaam Ji. I wish to know here and educate myself as to whether Radha-Soamis are anti-Sikh and what rites or rituals performed by them put them attributed to this. I have read a bit about the life of some their preachers and also found that within sikh community, Radha-Soamis are not...
  12. V

    History Did The Punjabi Suba Movement Do Any Good To Punjab Or Sikhs ?

    Satnaam Ji. Bewildered by Treachory from Nehru and Gandhi, Kharak Singh had raised this movement as a face-saver. What was intended to achieve ? I guess a Sikh Chief Minister who could have greater chance to come to power and loot the Public money as his successor Badal...
  13. V

    General Sikhism's Recent History. What Are The Causes Of Sikhi's Various Problems?

    SSA ji. Of late, events like Beadbi of Guru Granth Sahib, Sikh Jokes, etc and other larger problems like Sikh Massacre have happened. What is root cause of the events like this keep happening, leaving aside "Envious HINDU", the term I loathe ?
  14. V

    1984 Anti-Sikh Pogrom Why Did The Struggle That Followed '84 Die?

    Harry Haller Ji, Thanks for correcting me. I am missing comma. I believe such slogans puts the Sikh community in offensive position, which the whole hindu community does not deserve. There are hindus who have utmost respect for Sikh gurus and laud their history, and constant sevadars of...
  15. V

    1984 Anti-Sikh Pogrom Why Did The Struggle That Followed '84 Die?

    Its is quite clearly sure that Baba Thakur Singh ji stated with utmost belief till end of his life that Sant ji is in Chardi Kala. Thats why while he left his body, within short period of time, Sant ji was declared shaheed. Now, one of singh above believes that may be he was informed wrongly...
Top