• Welcome to all New Sikh Philosophy Network Forums!
    Explore Sikh Sikhi Sikhism...
    Sign up Log in

Recent content by pervez

  1. P

    Halal Or Not Halal: What Is The Difference? By Amar Prakash Singh

    You are free to belive what you want. The jewish once a day "blessing" is a recent phenemona. Many traditional jews still do it individualy. Thus muslims accept the meat from such jews. Also any muslim can slaughter animal as wittnessed in south asia and many muslim countries. In the west small...
  2. P

    Islam Is Halal Meat Scientifically Proven Right?

    First thanks for the brother epithet. It is welcome and i might say expected from a sikh. You may be confusing me for some one else though. I have not used any scientific explanation for halal. Nor is my purpose is to prove which is better/correct halal or non halal. Each to his own way. My...
  3. P

    Islam Is Halal Meat Scientifically Proven Right?

    Actually it is the other way round. Chicken peck at everything that does not mean they eat everything. Of course chicken can eat their shit but dont do so normally. It is modern(as you say proper farms) farms that make chicken eat shit in form of feed and also making it so difficult to avoid...
  4. P

    Islam Is Halal Meat Scientifically Proven Right?

    These fantasies are in the mind. Repeating them again and again might give some satisfaction but not make them facts. The muslim method of slaughtering an animal is not to do it slowly. That is not the criterion. The point is to cut the throat without severing the spinal cord. This method...
  5. P

    Islam Is Halal Meat Scientifically Proven Right?

    Ask a veternarian he will tell you if chickens eat excrement.
  6. P

    Halal Or Not Halal: What Is The Difference? By Amar Prakash Singh

    Non-muslims can have whatever food they wish to in Muslim countries. Thus pork and alcohol is available even in Saudi Arabia. In many Muslim countries Christians raise pigs and manufacture alcohol for their own consumption.
  7. P

    Halal Or Not Halal: What Is The Difference? By Amar Prakash Singh

    It is in recent times the Jews have accepted the method of kosher where in the prayer at the beggining and end of the day at a slaughter house suffices to make the whole days production kosher. This was not the case earlier. I dare say that there might be many non western Jewish communites who...
  8. P

    India India’s ‘silent’ Prime Minister Becomes A Tragic Figure

    It was a mistake by MMS to tackle the Nuclear bill at the instance of US this is cause of major problems for him and India. US expected that it will get access to Indian nuclear industry and gain access to Indian market in retail and have India generally follow US strategic guidelines especially...
  9. P

    Islam Is Halal Meat Scientifically Proven Right?

    I agree with Kabir Ji on Khichree!! Maa black beans are just fantastic. I agree with you on alcohol though I have only smelt it. Sukhi roti may be good for the soul I better develop a taste for it.
  10. P

    Islam Is Halal Meat Scientifically Proven Right?

    I think you are mistaken here. I dont see any muslim feeling guilty about eating Halal meat. I dont see where you get that from my posts. Still thanks for the sympthetic advice. If I ever feel guilty of eating halal I will remember your advice. One of the critera for Halal in the health of the...
  11. P

    Islam Is Halal Meat Scientifically Proven Right?

    I dont want to jump into an argument. Just want to inform in case there is lack of clarity. Of course people are entitled to their beliefs. Evidence from scientific methods only informs us to some extent and often is not always conclusive in many areas. Agreed a veterinarian may know more than...
  12. P

    Controversial Punjabi Language On The Decline?

    many languages do not have their own script. Like Turkish, Bhasa Malaysia, French, etc. Turkish used to be written in Arabic script and now a days in roman script same with Bhasa Malaysia. I dont see any reason which punjabi will be dead. I dont speak punjabi but Im told that many arabs in UAE...
  13. P

    Polygamy And Sikhism

    Polygamy or keeping mistresses is the same as far as child production is concerned in older times. Most people who could afford do have multiple women wifes or mistresses this is true even today. To look at absolute numbers of population in countries is ridiculous and immature. Population is...
  14. P

    Halal Or Not Halal: What Is The Difference? By Amar Prakash Singh

    I doubt the veracity of this story. I have seen this story(not the same as you have quoted from memory) in Bawa Muhaiyaddeen website and it is supposed to be an Hadith. There is no reference number of the Hadith so it is difficult to veryify how strong and accepted this Hadith(if it is a...
  15. P

    Halal Or Not Halal: What Is The Difference? By Amar Prakash Singh

    This is regarding the Sacrifice of animals at time of Hajj. The slaughtering of animals for regular eating has slightly different rules and does not constitute sacrifice. Holy Quran Chapter 22 Surah Hajj verse 37: 37It is not their (the sacrificial animal's) meat nor their blood that reaches...
Top