• Welcome to all New Sikh Philosophy Network Forums!
    Explore Sikh Sikhi Sikhism...
    Sign up Log in

Recent content by Manisha

  1. Manisha

    Bhagats Bhagat Jis

    Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh ji. From what I know, I understand that the Bhagat Jis in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji were from different backgrounds and faiths and they were highly spiritual. But I just wondered, when they met on an encounter with Guru Ji, if they then when on to...
  2. Manisha

    Who's In Control?

    That definitely puts things into perspective for me, so thanks a lot! :thumbsuppp:
  3. Manisha

    Who's In Control?

    WJKK WJKF ji. <o:p> </o:p> As I’ve been reading Gurbani a lot more and trying to contemplate it, I came across a question (that I asked myself while trying to understand Guru Ji’s message) which kind of confused me. <o:p> </o:p> There are many references in Gurbani that emphasise on how...
  4. Manisha

    Fools Who Wrangle Over Flesh

    I agree, thank you for that, Randip Ji. By the way, so would you say books are more reliable than internet sites (which I find hard to figure out whether they are biased towards one view or not)? And I strongly agree with all your points but mostly point 3 as, Guru Ji's were there to be our...
  5. Manisha

    Fools Who Wrangle Over Flesh

    Randip Ji I didn't know that, but I heard that story first off my brother, so then I tried to find a website stating that incident. Randip Ji, I too say never. I didn't say or mean to portray that Guru Ji's were vengeful, as when I said the snake had bit the man, I didn't mean that Guru Ji...
  6. Manisha

    Fools Who Wrangle Over Flesh

    The very first comment by Randip Ji is very educational, even to me as I was once a fool who wrangled over flesh.. For me, the reason behind my "wrangling" was definitely a lack of knowledge, so when I sought supposedly factual answers from others, even they had a lack of knowledge caused by...
  7. Manisha

    Comment by 'Manisha' in media 'Sikhism'

    This is nice.
  8. Manisha

    A Sikh Wearing A Cap?

    Re: Wearing a cap I’m not sure whether my point of view would be of any help, especially as you, Jasvinder Ji are looking for evidence.. Don’t be offended when I say this, but I too used to think like yourself, I will only ever believe anything about anything if only evidence is there...
  9. Manisha

    Sikh News Body Of Murdered Sikh Guru Returns To India

    Re: Body of murdered Sikh guru returns to India (AFP via Yahoo! News) 1st of all, where the hell did Dalit come from - why are there so many "names" for Ravidass followers? And that's true, because of such extreme actions towards the Sant, even my family (parents/uncles/aunties) get...
  10. Manisha

    Sikh News Body Of Murdered Sikh Guru Returns To India

    Re: Body of murdered Sikh guru returns to India (AFP via Yahoo! News) Well yeah, because everybody knows Guru means teacher, so everyone uses this only in the form to express 'teacher' - So it's used for everything even relating to stupid things - Not in the same way that Sikhism is formed...
  11. Manisha

    Caste System In Sikhism: Why?

    First of all, my pleasure and thank you Gyani Ji.. Now.. Like you said, you never imagined to see this type of treatment in 21st Century.. However, I think this doesn't happen in Western countries but without a doubt these LEDC (less economically developed/poor) countries have not...
  12. Manisha

    Caste System In Sikhism: Why?

    Lol.. I get you too.. Dalsingh.. But like I said this subject is subjective.. I understand all views.. Yet I'm not in any position to say which is which.. i.e. Which is correct/false..
  13. Manisha

    Caste System In Sikhism: Why?

    Well, Randip Ji, This can be a subjective subject as to why the caste sytem evolved (if that's what you're asking).. Like you've said, you may be wrong.. Only I know of others interpretations.. So I don't really know myself.. However when you said this: I believe it to be interesting...
  14. Manisha

    Caste System In Sikhism: Why?

    Gurfateh Gyani Ji.. Now when this student said: We’re referring back to what we said 1 of our main problem is – elders’ influence on youths.. Perfect example.. Do you know the student’s family? As, you said yourself you are an elder – but far from what these illusioned elders are; so I...
  15. Manisha

    Caste System In Sikhism: Why?

    Hmm.. I didn't know that.. But now that I do, I agree with what you're saying.. :yes:
Top