Recent content by khalsa1469

ByGaurav Singh Like so many other issuesthat contemporary Sikhs choose to deal with, the issue Dasam Granth is contrived and, indeed, a "red herring" (in that, it is meant to divert attention). I largely agree with Sardar I. J. Singh's take on things in his article onSikhchic.comand would like...

Dear Ambarsaria, Thank you for taking the time to engage. My responses are in dark red. Akal Sahai! Gaurav Singh

Dear Ishna, I thank you for your support and look forward to your feedback on the specific value you derive. That is, should you see fit to share it. All the very best...

As per spnadmin ji's suggestion, I am posting part of the 1st Paurhi. Please visit my website to read the intro and the other Paurhi(an). You may also visit the Facebook page created for "Siddh Gosht: A Dialog on Empowered Living" to engage with other readers, post comments, etc. Your...

Dear all, Vahgur ji ka Khalsa, Vahgur ji ki Fateh! It is a pleasure to see that there are so many on SPN interested in learning and growing thru dialogue. I invite you all to visit my website www.1infinite.com, where I have begun posting from my book "Siddh Gosht: A Dialog on Empowered...

Like most important aspects of Being, this is not an either/or situation. Perhaps, the question arises from lack of clarity about the nature of one's Being, and the meaning of Seva and Simran. The fundamental fact is that there is only 1. Being connected with that realization is Simran...

Dear all, Every work by an interpreter (and we are all interpreters) is a snapshot of his/her understanding at a particular time. Each of the above mentioned scholars may well have grown to change their mind about their earlier attempts. So, let us do our best to understand what is in front...

Dear Jarnail Singh ji, Vahgur ji ka Khalsa, Vahgur ji ki Fateh! I shall respond with my interpretation of Siddh Gosht (hopefully soon). Meanwhile, I thank you for discussing the critical need for a grounding in Gurbani grammar. It is important for seekers of Gurmat. There is something...

Vir Randip Singh, The important question is not whether Zafarnama is or is not genuine. Let's make an effort to go deeper - Even if Guru Gobind Singh wrote Zafarnama, would we be correct in calling it Gurbani? If not, then what relevance does it have? My answer to that is that it is a...

I have written something that sheds light upon this question. Please see the first point of discussion. "Dasam" Granth - A Look at the Core Problems By Gaurav Singh Like so many other issuesthat contemporary Sikhs choose to deal with, the issue Dasam Granth is contrived and, indeed, a...

Re: Who Is the Present Guru of the Sikhs? I have written something that sheds light upon this question. Please see the first point of discussion. "Dasam" Granth - A Look at the Core Problems related thread at...