• Welcome to all New Sikh Philosophy Network Forums!
    Explore Sikh Sikhi Sikhism...
    Sign up Log in

Recent content by JustCurious

  1. J

    Islam Why Not Halal Meat?

    yes extremism, both religious and secular, is a serious concern.
  2. J

    Gurus Was Guru Nanak A Good Father?

    I have never mentioned my faith for, what I can see now, was a good reason. I have never mentioned that I am a follower or Islam or any other religion. Regardless of this you have spouted so much hatred for Islam. There have also been subtle insults against the Jewish faith. I thought Sikhism...
  3. J

    Islam Is Halal Meat Scientifically Proven Right?

    I am confused what this has to do with the topic of this topic entitled "Is halal meat scientifically proven right?".
  4. J

    Gurus Was Guru Nanak A Good Father?

    It is a historical fact that Guru Nanak went gallivanting around India, in this regard I have not presumed anything. And as a result of this he left behind a wife and 2 small children without their father. This too is fact. I have to confess that over the past several hours I had not been...
  5. J

    Islam Is Halal Meat Scientifically Proven Right?

    Oh dear what a mess! Where to start to clean up your many misunderstandings? How about with your dismissal of a SCIENTIFIC experiment that was held by a professor and doctor who proved with science not "speculations" & "opinions" that the stun bolt method caused more pain to the animal and...
  6. J

    Gurus Was Guru Nanak A Good Father?

    I am surprised how you think Guru Nanak could have taught his kids anything of any value if he was off gallivanting around India for 28 years, which surely would have been throughout his kids' formative years! According to Wikipedia's page on Sri Chand (Guru Nanak's oldest son) he was raised by...
  7. J

    Islam Why Not Halal Meat?

    You're talking as if the early days of Sikhism were during the stone ages. It was only 500 hundred years ago which is not that long ago compared to other older religions, and I am pretty sure historical records from 500 years ago would be better preserved than ones from 2000 and more years ago...
  8. J

    Islam Is Halal Meat Scientifically Proven Right?

    hps62: Are you a tiger or a human being?
  9. J

    Islam Is Halal Meat Scientifically Proven Right?

    Hi there SikhEngineer, welcome to the discussion. Once again I am not very knowledgeable on all things Islam or in fact in any religion, but I am interested in learning about different belief systems. When I see something that is incorrect according to my understanding about any religion then...
  10. J

    Gurus Was Guru Nanak A Good Father?

    Maybe if he was there for his sons they wouldn't have turned out the way they did, and would have been proud Sikhi followers. Also are you now claiming that Guru Nanak's wife was also somehow divine and so did not require the physical and emotional love and attention she would have presumably as...
  11. J

    Islam Why Do Sikhs Look Down On Other Religions?

    What I said was and I will repeat for your clarity "speaking to followers of Sikhism and from reading some of the literature (no mention of SGGS)". From my interactions now with you you are just re-inforcing these feelings! This is exactly the attitude I get even when discussing face to face...
  12. J

    Gurus Was Guru Nanak A Good Father?

    I see you presume I am a Muslim and hence the volley of insults hurled towards me! Once again you make your hatred of Islam (in particular) and other religions in general clear! If I had said I was a Christian/Jew/Hindu etc I wonder what insults I could have expected to receive. For the last...
  13. J

    Gurus Was Guru Nanak A Good Father?

    And lo and behold we have come complete circle. It seems to me that you may not have any answers to my questions, hence this little game you're playing with me. Who would have thought asking a question on a Sikh forum could be so tiring! :-(
  14. J

    Islam Why Not Halal Meat?

    "Hunting purely for pleasure is a relatively late development" = not true. Hunting for pleasure has existed since antiquity. A quick search on Wikipedia/general Internet can confirm this. Just to be clear, hunting for sport and not for meat for food would be considered immoral and cruel (as in...
  15. J

    Islam Why Not Halal Meat?

    So how do I make sense of this verse? You kill living beings, and call it a righteous action. Tell me, brother, what would you call an unrighteous action? If you religious people are doing 'religious' killing for meat, then what is Adharam (atheism)? If you are a religious person then whom...
Top