Recent content by explorer

Respect Gyani ji, Respectfully, I beg to differ with you on few points : 1> Bhai Gurdas ji even composed after the compilation of SGGS clearly indicates that the his compositions were respcted within the Panth. The very mention of Guru Hargobind Sahib validates this fact. And also its...

Gyani ji, I respect the honesty of your opinions however i am not sure whether they are correct for the simple reasons: 1> You assume that Bhai Gurdas ji' composition didn't make the grade. However Professor Sahib Singh has presented a different view which been prevalent earlier also...

Gyani ji, This is looking at glass half-empty approach. You acknowledge that there are Vaars and Kabits composed by Bhai Gurdaas ji. However you donot address the point, why did he compose them at all, when he knew that each of the Gurus upto Guru Arjan Dev ji have composed bani and made...

Aman ji, Guru Fateh, Thanks for the help. Calling polyglot does not amount to disrespect for sure. However I was wondering how do we know that he was a polygot. Do we have source/evidence on this? Thanks!! Explorer

Tejwant ji, Guru Fateh!! You original post has no greatness; just portraying all the Gursikhs who says something beyond SGGS as mislead peole- who have missed the gurmat train. SGGS is the one and only one living guru for sikhs; this fact is stands unchallanged. However,we have Bhai...

Tejwant ji, Guru Fateh!! You have a one point agenda i.e any body who speaks of something beyond SGGS; paint him as a discreditor. Looks like you have started loving rabbits; I have few more rabbits in your sewa. I wonder what do think about Bhai Gurdas ji who composed Vaars and Kabit...

Giani ji, Again only SGGS is the guru and no one else is the guru. My disappointment is that we agree to quote prof. sahib singh ji who himself translated Jaap Sahib and other banis. And then also people stand still on a blind folded argument, i feel there is no point in discussion. This...

Tejwant ji, When people run out of the arguments, they keep repeating same thing again and again; half of your post goes on telling me that i am discrediting SGGS becuase i am saying that there is another granth based on writings from Dasam Pita which is known as Dasam Granth(compiled by Bhai...

Tejwant ji, Let me make it clear, SGGS is the only guru of Sikhs, if there is an problem in the reflection of the same thought through any of my previous posts or if somebody feels that i think otherwise. Secondly, I have nowhere mentioned that DG has to be embraced as Guru of Sikhs or Dasam...

Respected Giani ji, The concern is not that I am opposed to what Dr. Jaggi did? The issue is about our approach to the issue and assumptions. I quoted Giani Ditt Singh ji because "Singh Sabha Canada" who has been spearheading this campaign in the recent times mentions on their home pages...

All your views are not your own views, they are very much dependant on the understanding of the others. If we are ready to look into what Principal Harbhajan Singh says then why not examine others like Giani Ditt Singh ji. Why should we should we consider Dr. Jaggi's opinion...

If thats the case, then nowhere Guru Sahib mentions in SGGS that sikhs should go through the Pahul Ceremony and should wear 5K's How can one decide now, if its not mentioned in the SGGS by Guru Sahib himself. Going by the same logic, if it was so important and necessary than why was not it...

Does that mean we all have been mislead till date and none except Dr. Jaggi has been able to find the truth?

This is your first post. "All these pretenders are blowing their own whistles while riding on their own ego trains as they have deliberately missed the Gurmat train." Can you please elaborate did Giani Ditt Singh went for a ego ride when he wrote Durga Prabodh. Pls answer specific to the...

Tejwant ji, Its for the people to on the forum to decide who has failed in grasping what!! I wonder you are discussing and trying to learn (as per your posts) from people on this forum who are also not our Dasam Pita; however when I mentioned Giani Ditt Singh ji, you politely asked me : Is...