Welcome to SPN

Register and Join the most happening forum of Sikh community & intellectuals from around the world.

Sign Up Now!

Objective Morality: Ayn Rand, the discussion on Altruism

Discussion in 'Sikh Sikhi Sikhism' started by Sinister, Jan 4, 2008.

  1. Sinister

    Sinister
    Expand Collapse
    SPNer Supporter

    Joined:
    May 4, 2006
    Messages:
    907
    Likes Received:
    394
    Hello Members and guests;

    Let’s start the New Year by absorbing something from this discussion. Ayn Rand, author of many great works and definitely one of the most recognized contemporary philosophers, discusses objective morality and the dangers of altruism. To a large part it seems like a continuation of Nietzsche’s elitism; but it is a little different.


    YouTube - Ayn Rand Phil Donahue Interview Part 1 of 5

    YouTube - Ayn Rand Phil Donahue Interview Part 2 of 5

    YouTube - Ayn Rand Phil Donahue Interview Part 3 of 5

    YouTube - Ayn Rand Phil Donahue Interview Part 4 of 5

    YouTube - Ayn Rand Phil Donahue Interview Part 5 of 5


    And if any true “anti-Sikh” exists, I assure you it is this woman … lol…although she probably has never heard of Sikhism, she is definitively its most dangerous opponent… even more so than the secretive and infamous RSS I hear about frequently or the Muslims.

    Although I do not agree with some of the things she said (especially with regards to religion and some of her views on foreign policy), her arguments are nonetheless “genuine” (they ring with “truthiness”)….especially when she tells us the dangers of too much altruism. The idea that we hold altruists in too high a regard in society is, sinister (which is why it should be discussed). She addresses what Sikhs love to call ‘ego’. (I would love to discuss this viewpoint)

    Society has become more in tune with giving credit to everyone rather than those who deserve it. And the new generation that is growing up is being deluded into thinking that this is the progression of mankind when it may be the hindrance. At the very beginning she talks about how the image of being humble and sharing credit has become so ludicrous that it has started to repress our true emotions. She holds emotions in high regard as any Romanticist would do.

    Her thesis is the direct opposite of Nanak’s message:
    Hukamai Andar Sabh Ko, Bahar Hukam Na Kohe
    Nanak Hukmai jai bujai ta Homai ka’hai n ko’ai

    This is also a very powerful piece that Americans might find interesting. Rand’s vision of America:

    YouTube - AYN RAND's message to the GOP CANDIDATES


    Although Rand thought on large macro scale social models, she did not ascribe to the construction of any Utopian society…if you read her works she was against it. How does this bode with Sikhi? Should Sikhi be about achieving a utopian state of mind and Morality (note the capital on Morality)? Or better yet, is Sikh morality Utopian?

    I guess it boils down to:
    Did religion make morality or did morality make religion?

    I’m not here to debate anyone so feel free to leave your thoughts and don’t forget to watch those videos!

    Cheers
     
    #1 Sinister, Jan 4, 2008
    Last edited by a moderator: Jan 30, 2009
  2. Loading...

    Similar Threads Forum Date
    Guru Nanak Dev ji being asked: Why leave home, travel, the objectives and mission .. 6 Sidh Gosht Sep 15, 2012
    God-Subjective & Objective view points Spiritual Articles Jan 29, 2006
    Sikh Objective of Meditation Gurmat Vichaar Aug 30, 2005
    Pacific New Book Finds Music's Magical Powers Objectively Verifiable (pzone via Yahoo! Australia & NZ Financ Breaking News Jun 21, 2005
    Humanism Religion, Secular Morality and Slavery Interfaith Dialogues Sep 19, 2011

Share This Page