Dear Truth Seeker,
Wahe Guru Ji Ka Khalsa Wahe Guru ji Ki Fateh!
I am happy that you asked for clarification of my points. I am not that much learned as Mr. Amarpal Singhji but I will try to clarify my points to the best of knowledge.
Your first point is: a) Is it a fact or an assumption? Did Guru Nanak say that he is commencing a new religion and asked to be followed? b) Did Bala (Hindu) and Mardana (Muslim) become Sikhs?
My answer to that is Guru Nanak never commenced or launched new religion and asked Bala and Mardana to become Sikhs. Guru Nanak was born like other children but was always a Truth Seeker. I am giving few examples:
1. When he was sent to Maulvi for learning, Guru Nanak questioned the Maulvi about the meaning of “Alf”. When Maulvi could not answer, Guru Nanak told him the meaning of “Alf” as “Alf Allah Noor Upaya Kudrat Kae Sabh Bande”. 2. When Pandit asked Guru Nanak to wear the “Janaoo” , Guru Nanak questioned the Pandit about the significance of it. 3. When Guru Nanak saw people giving water to Sun, he questioned the purpose. When the answer was “sending water to their Pitter (forefathers), Guru Nanak did not satisfy from the answer. Guru Nanak started throwing water to the opposite direction. When people question him, Guru Nanak replied that his farms are dry without water and he is sending water to his farm. This was very simple answer to the orthodox Brahmins and others, regarding sending water to their forefathers in heaven. 4. When at Mecca, Guru Nanak was sleeping, the Maulvi asked Guru Nanak, why he was sleeping while keeping his feet toward Allah. Guru Nanak simply asked Maulvi to move the feet to the direction, where there is no Allah. So these are the few examples which made Guru Nanak as a God sent man with the Truth. When the people realized that Guru Nanak is the only person who can lead them to the right path, they started following him and became his disciples i.s. Shish (later on known as Sikh). These Shish (Sikhs) became the new sect or group or religion of Sikhism. This is what I visualise the Sikhism. Everybody has his/her own way of visualising the same thing with different perspectives. Upto Guru Teghbahadurji, these Sikhs were the followers of the Gurus teaching. Guru Gobind Singhji baptized these people after Amrit Pan and made them Khalsa (Pure) prescribed them a uniform of 5Ks.
Your second point is: Why do you think God created humanity?
My answer is: God is inside human being which tell us what is right and what is wrong. God does not live anywhere else. Thus in my opinion, humanity is a creation of human being and nothing else. Without parents, child cannot be born and all Gurus and Paghambers were born though their parents.
Your third point is: Does it mean 5Ks are unnecessary?
My answer is: 5Ks are very necessary for those who are Baptized. A simple example is that when one joins army or police force, he is bound to wear the prescribed uniform (to be recognized to belong to that force) and following the code of conduct prescribe for him. Without joining police force, if one wears the uniform, he is know as impersonator and if caught, is punished severely. Likewise, if a man is not Baptized and wear 5Ks, he/she is liable to be punished in the court of Guru Gobind Singhji.
Your last question is:
“Finally, what are your views regarding re-birth as Amarpal believes that "those who are not able to merge have to take rebirth"?
My personal view is that there is no rebirth. Gurbani says: “Jeon Jal Mae Jal Aiy Khatan, Tyon Joaty Sangh Jot Samanah”. This belief of re-birth was the inception of Brahmins, who used to tell the stories to the innocent people to earn their livelihood.
Rest, Amarpalji has a vast knowledge and study of Gurbani and can explain this as well as my other points, in detail.
With love and respect for all. If any of my views, hurt somebody, I wholeheartly apologize for that.
Thanks
Pul Chuk Maf!