Welcome to SPN

Register and Join the most happening forum of Sikh community & intellectuals from around the world.

Sign Up Now!

Sects Dera Ballan accused of plagiarism in preparing holy book 'Amritbani' of Guru Ravidass

Discussion in 'History of Sikhism' started by spnadmin, Apr 25, 2013.

  1. spnadmin

    spnadmin United States
    Expand Collapse
    1947-2014 (Archived)
    SPNer Supporter

    Jun 17, 2004
    Likes Received:
    Dera Ballan accused of plagiarism in preparing holy book 'Amritbani' of Guru Ravidass

    IP Singh


    JALANDHAR: Serious differences have cropped up within Adi-dharmi (Ravidassia) with a century and half old Dera of village Chak Hakim near Phagwara alleging plagiarism by Dera Sachkhand Ballan, the largest dera of the community which announced to found a separate religion three years back, in preparing 'Amrit Bani' Granth.

    This Phagwara based Dera has alleged that the verses contained in this 'Amirtbani' Granth were not of Guru Ravidass, as projected by Dera Ballan, but authored by Sant Hira Dass in his over century old Granth 'Ravidass Deep'. however Dera Ballan has denied the charges.

    Addressing a press conference here Mahant Parshotam Lal, a descendant of Sant Hira Dass - who established Dehra Guru Ravidass Mandir Chak Hakim in nineteenth century - even provided the copies of pages from the Ravidass Deep Granth, completed by Sant Hira Dass in 1908 in his handwriting and then getting it first published in 1912, from which he alleged that verses were copied by Dera Sachkhand Ballan.

    Highlighting striking similarities in the text of the two Granths, Parshotam Lal pointed out that wherever name of Sant Hira Dass was written in the versus as author of Ravidass Deep it was deleted by making some changes and it was shown in 'Amritbani Granth' as if these were written by Guru Ravidass. Stating that around 80 percent of the text was copied he alleged that this included Mangla Charan, Naran Mah, 46 Shabadsand 105 Shalokswere copied almost ditto except the name of Sant Hira Dass.

    Challenging Dera ballan to come out with the original texts from which they have taken the versus to include in 'Amritbani' Parshotam Lal said that Dera Ballan should either tender an apology in 15 days 'for misleading the community" and clarify the things or he threatened that he would pursue legal action against the Dera. On this occasion All Indian Adi-Dharam Mission president S S Heera and Samaj Bachao Morcha convenor gian chand were also present.

    He said that he even met Dera Ballan head Sant Niranjan Dass and his deputy Sant Surinder Dass Bawa on the issue after he discovered these "Plagiarism" in December but latter was adamant and refused to clarify the issue in public.

    However, when contacted, Sant Surinder Dass Bawa claimed that versus of Guru Ravidass was contained in various granths and they had these sources with them. He rather alleged that Sant Hira Dass inserted his name in the Bani (compositions) of Guru Ravidass. He rubbished the charges of plagiarism and held that all the versus contained in Amritbani were of Guru Ravidass.
    • Like Like x 2
  2. Loading...

    Similar Threads Forum Date
    Sikh News Beating Of Sikh In Hyderabad Raised In LS Breaking News Jul 22, 2016
    Reinstatement Of Harry Haller As SPN Moderator Announcements Jun 21, 2016
    India 'Dera' followers, Sikhs clash in Moga Breaking News Jan 4, 2015
    Hyderabad Book Reviews & Editorials Dec 18, 2014
    Malaysia Seven-man Federal Court bench hearing ‘Allah’ case today Breaking News Mar 5, 2014

  3. Gyani Jarnail Singh

    Gyani Jarnail Singh Malaysia
    Expand Collapse
    Sawa lakh se EK larraoan
    Mentor Writer SPNer Contributor

    Jul 4, 2004
    Likes Received:
    This is only one link in a chain of events...
    First is the so called "terror" attack in VIENNA in which ONE of the Two heads of DERA BALLAN was assasinated..leaving the second one to "survive" and grab the leadership pole position in DERA BALLAN as Head Honcho
    Second link was the unprecedented VIOLENCE unleashed in Punjab on PUBLIC and SIKH Property in so called "rioting" because of the Vienna Incident. Surprisingly the Violence beagn almost SIMULTANEOUSLY with the Vienna incident - perhaps all preplanned ??
    Third was the Onslaught of Chmaar VS Jatt VIDEOS on You Tube...suddenly CASTE vs CASTE became hot topic..singer after singer snag about the glory of chmaars putt chmaaran de etc etc and attacked JATTS ( target is SIKHS because most jatts are sikhs )
    Fourth was the ATTACK on the SGGS via this new so called Amrti bani granth produced overnight by the Dera ballan Group and suddenly disputes began in Gurdwaras to remove the SGGS and install the ABG !! Another link leading to DIVISION among SIKHS..

    2. Despite a huge Granth of Kabir Jis writings known as Kabir Panthi granth..no CHHIMBA vs Jatt divide or attempts to install this KPG instead of SGGS in gurdawras has ever taken palce. The Kabir Granth is way more authentic . Kabir was a Julaha/Chhimba?weaver caste - but unlike the Ravidassis chamaars there has been no attempt to raise the Kabir bogey as is being done to Bhagat ravidass Ji and attempt to divide the SIKHS and cause fights in Gurdwaras.

    This plagirisation and its perperators should be taken to the full extenet of the Law.
    • Like Like x 4

Share This Page