1. No body knows where the shaheeds ( and everyone else who "departs" ) WENT....and where and inn what condition their "souls" are ??? Di they "need" our prayers/help ??
2. GURBANI is AMPLY CLEAR..NO ONE can HELP the "departed" in any way...either Before departing or after. The ONLY person who is helped is the ONE who did his/her OWN "Naam Simran"/Naam kamaii/followed GURBANI in his LIFE TIME..and thus EARNED the FRUITS of NAAM which COUNT in the hereafter.
GURU NANAK JI ILLUSTRATED THIS point so WELL at Kurkshetar where He Threw Water towards Kartarpur Punjab in front of MILLIONS..throwing water towards the SUN..for their Departed Ancestors.
Guru Ji declared..IF my WATER cannot reach PUNJAB..a few hundred miles away..how can YOURS reach the SUN..millions of miles away.
The "MILLIONS" never understood then..and they
DONT GET IT EVEN TODAY. They send "water"..we send "paaths/ardasses/guru ke langgar" SAME THING.
GURU NANAK the True Revolutionary..WROTE it all in His GURBANI, explained it all in His Visits..and even ILLUSTRATED IT GRAPHICALLY so that even the most dumb could GET IT....YET many still dont get it or dont want to.
THe BEST WAY to "Commemeorate" the Sacrifices of these and other Shaheeds..is NOT ritually reciting paaths... ITS through READONG GURBANI....IMBIBING ITS TEACHINGS in our DAILY LIVES..so that we BECOME LIVING MIRROR SHAHEEDS...of the likes of Baba Deep Singh Ji, Bhai mani Singh Ji, Baba Ajit Singh, Jhujaar Singh, Zorawar Singh fateh Singh, Baba Banda Singh Ji and the 1984 martyrs..etc etc etc..the LONG UNENDING LINE of such GREAT MEN to continue !!! WE MUST LIVE GURBANI....such "ritulised ginntee minntees are simply advertisement campaigns....records of which are sent up daily...million Chaupees..billion Sukhmanis..etc etc..Sehaj paaths and Akhand Paaths by the various Deras continue to set such RECORDS all the time...and YET we see more and more SIKHS..discarding their Dastaars..more and more sikhs losing their Kirpans....is THIS "LIVING GURBANI" ?? Does GURBANI COLOUR US in its RAANG ?? WHY ?? Is it a Failure of GURBANI or our failure ?? I DECLARE its OUR FAILURE...just like the Lallaera or Colour Artist who fails to follwo proper instructions to COLOUR your Dastaar/Chunni will sell you a dastaar that LOSES its COLOUR after the first WASH..KACHA RAANG...such ways of Reading Gurbani..leads to KACHA RAANG..NOT the TRUE PAKKA RAANG that GURBANI is sure to Give our LIVES.
Reference:: Sikh Philosophy Network http://www.sikhphilosophy.net/showthread.php?t=25105Reference:: Sikh Philosophy Network http://www.sikhphilosophy.net/showthread.php?t=25105
Bhul Chuk Maaf... I DONT and NEVER support such Campaigns.




:advocate :