But who is equating it to the SGGS? I don't see the common sikh removing SGGS and replacing it with Dasam Granth. Most people haven't even read the Dasam Granth. So how can you say people are calling it Guru? Time and time again it has been said by just about every member who has posted about...
I don't really understand what you saying or what your point is but i'll go off of what i got from what you wrote. Well, Iqbal Singh (Jathedar Patna Sahib) has two wives. Gurbachan Singh (Jathedar Akal Takhat) visited the Dera of Chicago Baba (who was caught in motel with a woman other than his...
Re: Tankhah Against Ragi Issued
Dude, who made them top ranking authority? Last time I checked, Guru Gobind Singh Ji said the SGGS is Guru and know is above that. They are only human. Stop treating them like they are above that. And Panj Pyare are different from Jathedars. Two totally different...
So we shouldn't try and interpret anything for ourselves? And what makes someone else qualified to interpret it? Basically, you are saying I am ignorant and shouldn't try and read and interpret for myself. Instead I should listen to other peoples interpretations? What makes them qualified to...
Re: Tankhah Against Ragi Issued
You are extremely ill-informed. The jathedars are not panj pyare. He is going in front of jathedars. I can wear a military uniform, but that does not make me suited to became a general in the army and command troops. Wearing a Uniform doesn't make you a good...
But why does it matter what brahm gyanis think? Why can't we just read the Dasam Granth and decide for ourselves if it contains lessons or information of value. If it does then it is good. To each his own. We should make our own decisions by doing our own research. For ex. Teachers in Elementary...
Re: Tankhah Against Ragi Issued
I am not so much worried about the chance of violence breaking out as I am of a discussion not taking place. We must find a way to make sure that the sangat does not constantly interrupt the discussion. Constant interruptions and yelling by sangat could make it...
Re: Tankhah Against Ragi Issued
I am against closed meetings. I think that at the very least, they should allow 2 or 3 people to go inside with Ragi so it is not 5 against one. And if there is an open meeting, they have to insure that violence does not break out. It is a common concept...
well if you watch the videos posted in the faridabad thread, the individuals were from Mata Sahib Kaur Gurmat College. And the spitting incident is going on in a corner, the video is not of high quality (cell phone i think) so you can't see it but there is a lady arguing with other females and...
Re: Tankhah Against Ragi Issued
Right but then you must insure that fights do not break out. If you are going to have an open discussion about this issue at akal takhat you must insure that sanctity of SGGS and the gurdwaras is observed. In todays day and age, it has become obvious that some...
I don't think these are the guys who caused the ruckus. They just made a video about the faridabad incident and were defending the people that were spitting on dastars and causing trouble. Obviously they are anti dasam granth.
Re: Tankhayia Against Ragi Issued
Sir I have offered a solution. I believe that ragi should be allowed to bring a few supporters of his with him. Where there are 5 jathedars, he should be able to bring 3 or 4 people with him. If this is held in front of sangat, can you truly say that you...
Is that the same guy (in yellow dastar) who was defending the people that caused a ruckus in a gurdwara and were spitting on ladies dastars in faridabad? Just wondering.
Re: Tankhayia Against Ragi Issued
See I have no problem with having decisions made at Akal Takhat, but it is only right if those making the decision were unbiased and uncorrupted. To send a man into a closed room with 5 people who have views opposite from his and have them judge him is not...
Re: Tankhayia Against Ragi Issued
but at the same time, don't you think that with all the fighting that has broken out over this issue inside gurdwaras around the globe, it is not wise to hold a discussion in front of open sangat? I mean, I doubt that either side would even get to speak to one...
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.