• Welcome to all New Sikh Philosophy Network Forums!
    Explore Sikh Sikhi Sikhism...
    Sign up Log in

Recent content by Verma1

  1. V

    How Could Guru Nanak Visit Mecca If He Wasn't A Muslim?

    NOT TRUE it does not say this anywhere. In fact the Gurus all say all these things are to be AVOIDED. Another example of manipulated information to be used by people to do what they want. It is disgusting to even associate these things with the teachings of the Gurus. Read up the Panj Pyare...
  2. V

    Hinduism Does Sikhism Confirm The Existence Of Hindu Gods/Goddesses?

    It is true that people really should not talk about Hindusim or Sikhism if they dont know a thing about it. However this particular thread is about Hinduism, hence why I mentioned Hinduism only. The more I am reading the posts on this forum, its making me realise just how ignorant people...
  3. V

    How Could Guru Nanak Visit Mecca If He Wasn't A Muslim?

    As I said before, I myself am both Hindu and Sikh and therefore follow both religions deeply. As a result of studying and learning both religions, I have found that both religions are the same, however Sikhism has been manipulated on a huge scale now. The true meaning of the Gurus' Teachings...
  4. V

    Hinduism Does Sikhism Confirm The Existence Of Hindu Gods/Goddesses?

    Gyani Jurnail Singh - I STRONGLY disagree with you. Lord Vishnu did incarnate as Lord Rama and Lord Krishna. Hindu Gods and Goddesses ARE acknowledged in the Granth. I think it highly ignorant of you to say that They were just rajas. THis is highly untrue and shows your lack of knowledge...
  5. V

    Hinduism Does Sikhism Confirm The Existence Of Hindu Gods/Goddesses?

    As someone who is both Hindu and Sikh, the existence of Hindu Gods and Goddesses is most definitely acknowledged in the Granth. Sikhism says that one should not just perform religious duties and just worship idols only without meditation as this will not bring 'Mukti'. In order to gain Mukti...
  6. V

    How Could Guru Nanak Visit Mecca If He Wasn't A Muslim?

    This is a prime example of the Granth being manipulated and changed by people. Think about it, do you really think any Guru would say its ok to kill an ani,al or any other living being?!!!! Seriously, read the Granth and UNDERSTAND it more importantly and spot the information that has been...
  7. V

    How Could Guru Nanak Visit Mecca If He Wasn't A Muslim?

    kds1980 - do you know the actual meanings of the verses?! The Gurus are not rejecting the Vedas and never did. They explain what spiritual life should really be like. I said, todays Sikhs are very easily influenced and manipulated The title of this post confirms so after all, whoin their...
  8. V

    How Could Guru Nanak Visit Mecca If He Wasn't A Muslim?

    Tejwant Singh, I do not see christianity and islam in the same light as Hinduism, Buddhism, Jainism and Sikhism. Christianity has caused war, converting, etc not to the same extent as islam , but still has. Then theres islam, muslims actually do accept Jesus as one of their prophets and...
  9. V

    How Could Guru Nanak Visit Mecca If He Wasn't A Muslim?

    'Finding my way' I think you are confusing christianity and islam with Spiritual religions like Hindusim, Buddhism and Sikhism and to some extent Judaism. Firstly, the origin of christianity and islam were from violence. Christianity is based on Judaism and Jesus also went to India to learn...
  10. V

    How Could Guru Nanak Visit Mecca If He Wasn't A Muslim?

    Kds1980....where does Guru Nanak Dev Ji say he does not accept Vedic religion?!! Guru Nanak Dev Ji simply reiterated how people should live and only said people should not get caught up in religious practices if they are forgetting the main purpose of spirituality and religion. Vedic religion...
  11. V

    How Could Guru Nanak Visit Mecca If He Wasn't A Muslim?

    Sinner - you obviously need to read The Granth and actually understand it. You have underlined various parts of my paragraph stating your own opinions alongside. However, the simple fact is there was a war going on when Guru Nanak Dev Ji was born and He therefore wanted to create peace between...
  12. V

    How Could Guru Nanak Visit Mecca If He Wasn't A Muslim?

    Actually, Guru Nanak Dev Ji was born into a Hindu Kshatriya family. So the root of the Sikh religion lies in Hinduism. The Sikh religion was actuallycreated by Guru Gibind Singh Ji much later. Sikhism now has become a religion in its own right. Guru Nanak Dev Ji simply wanted to create peace...
  13. V

    How Could Guru Nanak Visit Mecca If He Wasn't A Muslim?

    As a simple answer - No, Guru Nanak Dev Ji and nor do Hindus and Sikhs believe in allah.
  14. V

    How Could Guru Nanak Visit Mecca If He Wasn't A Muslim?

    Kds1980, thanks for your post. The purpose of Guru Nanak Dev Ji going to muslim places was to show that there is no difference about what your background is because muslims cause so much trouble with religion. His aim was to create peace in the region, he never converted and WAS NEVER a...
  15. V

    Islam Was Guru Nanak A Muslim?

    Re: Was Guru Nanak a Muslim ? Sasriakal, I would just like to say please could you send this message out to all the Sikhs. It is so important to educate everyone that the clkaims these muslims make that Guru Nanak Ji was ase claims a to be abolished. They are false claims and like you said...
Top