• Welcome to all New Sikh Philosophy Network Forums!
    Explore Sikh Sikhi Sikhism...
    Sign up Log in

Recent content by venod

  1. V

    Gurmat : Who Is The Deciding Authority

    Dear harjas ji and Dhillon Sahib, I am not interested in indulging in something that may not be palatable. However, I do point out the significance of standardisation. I am happy with that I know. There are many things that are not put properlyin Rehat nama of SGPC but I do not feel like...
  2. V

    Sikhism : An Old Wine In - New Bottle

    Re: Sikhism : An old wine in -New Bottle Sorry Tejwant ji, I do not know where and who Drupti was. She is not a character of Gita. She appears in Epic of Mahabharta. Like wise Raam was incarnation or a prophet, it matters a little. Similary it matters not if Guru Nanak was a prophet or an...
  3. V

    Gurmat : Who Is The Deciding Authority

    Thanks to all, Respeted Harjas and Dhillon ji, You has written a long post. It is not a point of argument that 'waheguru' is a gurumantar or not. The main source of 'waheguru-gurumantar' lies outside the approved gurbani and hence it was suggested that one should arrive at some sort of...
  4. V

    Sikhism : An Old Wine In - New Bottle

    Re: Sikhism : An old wine in -New Bottle I acknowledge with thanks and humility the posts, of S.Vikram ji, Harjap ji, S. Pritpal ji, Vahe Guruseeker ji , S. Amar pal ji and Japji Sahib004 ji with thanks as these all illuminating in their own way. I am in my own way putting forth the...
  5. V

    Gurmat : Who Is The Deciding Authority

    Dear Tejwant ji, I fully agree that you have stated is correct. I have just stated that ‘wahegur’ is a term not reflective of any entity but of attributes that you have clarified . He is nameless as well. [10th Guru sahib] .Tru infinite cannot be named but we try to do so as we want to...
  6. V

    Understanding AGGS :Incoherent Lines

    There are many lines that appear to me as totally incoherent as if something is missing from SGGS.I want to seek clarifications. i have put it in Hard Talk so that I can express my views as well. Doubt no.1 The term Guru has appeared in the holy book at many places. Can You kindly explain...
  7. V

    Sikhism : An Old Wine In - New Bottle

    Re: Sikhism : An old wine in -New Bottle I do not want to attack anyone or any Guru ji. I want to disuss religion -sprituality with a sharp focus on Granth Sahib, Gita , Sikhi and other concepts including the revival and resurrection Of sikhi for this religion is totally misunderstood by the...
  8. V

    Gurmat : Who Is The Deciding Authority

    Mr Dhillon ji, Although, I do agree with you in principle but if we leave everything to everyone there are chances that most of the things would get distorted. Let us take the sacred word 'weahguru' . It does not owe its origin to Holy Granth, in the manner that something divine is associated...
  9. V

    Sikhism : An Old Wine In - New Bottle

    Re: Sikhism : An old wine in -New Bottle Respected Vikram ji, My previous account is blocked by the web and I have no intention to hurt the feelings Of my friends. If you like to have a discussion please state that you shall like to discuss. I am the last one to trouble you people. Regards
Top