• Welcome to all New Sikh Philosophy Network Forums!
    Explore Sikh Sikhi Sikhism...
    Sign up Log in

Recent content by sunsingh

  1. S

    Charitropakhyan [Part V] Charitropakhyan - Analysis And Clarifications Of Sri Sabudh Baach (Charitar No. 404)

    Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Guru Roop Sangat Jeo, Guruji has shown immense kirpa - the fifth article in the series is now complete. Sabudh Baach is a deeply engaging story, with many important moral lessons to be learnt from it. It provides a nice, in-depth analysis of various...
  2. S

    Are Brahmgyanis For Real?

    For a real jagriti, let us look at what Guru ji teaches instead of interpreting Gurbani as we see fit. The word bhramgyani is not a title, although some mistakenly use it as such. It instead describes the internal spiritual state of the seeker. The Satsangat is a garden, and if every once in a...
  3. S

    Charitropakhyan [Part IV] Charitropakhyan – Analysis And Clarifications Of Charitars 25 – 403 Bhai Prabjot Singh)

    Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Guru Roop Sangat Jeo, With Sri Guruji's kirpa, the fourth article in the Charitropakhyan series is now complete. This article provides a summary of important Charitars, from no. 25 - No. 403, and attempts to refute the baseless and illogical arguments...
  4. S

    Charitropakhyan [Part Iii] Charitropakhyan – Analysis And Clarifications Of Charitar 21-23 – Story Of (A)Noop Kaur (

    Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Guru Roop Sangat Jeo, With Guruji's blessings, here is an analysis of the (in)famous Charitar - The story of (A)noop Kaur. This is the Charitar that darshan ragi used to distort the essence of Charitropakhyan at Rochester, NY. We all know what happened...
  5. S

    Charitropakhyan [Part Ii] Charitropakhyan: Analysis And Clarification (Bhai Prabjot Singh)

    Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Guru Roop Sangat Jeo, With Waheguru Ji's blessings, here is part 2 of the ongoing series of articles on Charitropakhyan. This article provides plot descriptions of the Charitars 2 - 16, their importance, lessons to be learned, and clarifications of the...
  6. S

    Charitropakhyan [Part I] Charitropakhyan – Introduction And Analysis Of Chandi Charitar Khojeee (Bhai Prabjot Singh)

    re: Charitropakhyan: English translation and Analysis (from Khojee.com) das will post one part every day until the translation is finished.
  7. S

    Charitropakhyan [Part I] Charitropakhyan – Introduction And Analysis Of Chandi Charitar Khojeee (Bhai Prabjot Singh)

    re: Charitropakhyan: English translation and Analysis (from Khojee.com) Source: http://khojee.wordpress.com/2010/04/14/part-i-charitropakhyan-introduction-and-analysis-of-chandi-charitar/ Similar expressions can be seen in the beginning of Raas-Leela (dance and celebration) episode of...
  8. S

    Charitropakhyan [Part I] Charitropakhyan – Introduction And Analysis Of Chandi Charitar Khojeee (Bhai Prabjot Singh)

    Charitropakhyan - Introduction and Analysis of Charitar No.1 - Chandi Charitar Source http://khojee.wordpress.com/2010/04/14/part-i-charitropakhyan-introduction-and-analysis-of-chandi-charitar/ This composition of Sri Dasam Granth - completed at Sri Anandpur Sahib in Bikrami 1753 (1696 AD) -...
  9. S

    Mainstream Sikhi, Guru Panth, Guru Granth - Your Views

    Re: Best and Worst Sites on Sikhism? hmmm... I actually disagree. But I guess that's a discussion for another time, another thread. I'd like to note that Sarbloh.info website, that site does not accurately represent the views of nihangs. There are some things on that site that are unique to...
  10. S

    Q&A With Sant Jagjit Singh Ji Harkhowal

    vir ji, Baba Jagjit Singh ji is actually considered one of the most learned scholars in the panth, and has extensive knowledge of Dasam Bani and Sarbloh Bani. He does not promote sargun worship, but heavily promotes nirgun worship. He merely stated that worship by placing dhyain on sargun is...
  11. S

    Q&A With Sant Jagjit Singh Ji Harkhowal

    All of the Gurbani you have qouted does not condemn or even mention sargun worship. Absence of discussion on sargun worship does not equal condemnation. God exists in both sargun and nirgun forms. Worship of God in sargun or nirgun is allowed, but nirgun is emphasized as it is superior. Sargun...
  12. S

    Q&A With Sant Jagjit Singh Ji Harkhowal

    please provide even the slightest shred of proof from Gurbani backing up your assertion. Gurbani states that God exists in sargun as well as nirgun, see japji sahib for the examples, or numerous other shabads. Nowhere is sargun remembrance considered wrong. Baba Jagjit Singh ji, a student of...
  13. S

    Q&A With Sant Jagjit Singh Ji Harkhowal

    Gurbani in Guru Granth Sahib ji = Guru = God. To recognize this does not in any way limit worship or understanding of God to sargun only. God is both nirgun and sargun. Nowhere in Gurbani does it say that worship of the sargun aspect of waheguru is wrong. Nirgun is the highest and that is what...
  14. S

    Q&A With Sant Jagjit Singh Ji Harkhowal

    Nirgun worship is the highest form. However, like a child learning how to ride a bike using training wheels, sargun worship is sometimes a must for some people starting out on this path as nirgun worship is simply beyond them. nirgun worship should be the goal and mode for sikhs. According to...
Top