Recent content by ExploringSikhi

Sat Sri Akal everyone, some of you may recall my first thread on this forum in which I got the impression that most, if not all of you, reject the concepts of miracles in Sikhism. Indeed, I have been reading other threads on this site in which members say that they like Sikhism because it is...

Apologies for taking such a long time to post, been busy with coursework and midterms so haven't really had the chance. The three questions were as follows: 1) Show me where in the Qur'an it says all believers will go to hell. 2) Show me where in the Qur'an it says being Muslims doesn't...

Has faith that God will preserve the Qur'an. Things it is illogical to have faith in the hadiths. I hope you see the contradiction in your own text. It is not just the fact that you are a Qur'anist. You have made statements such as "all believers will go to hell" and "being a Muslim...

If she is doing that, then great, I say more power to her. I simply want her to state it explicitly, that this is HER interpretation of Islam, not anyone else's, and to make it clear that her beliefs are not shared by the vast majority of Muslims around the world. But as long as she tries to...

By the same token, you must then also reject the notion that the Qur'an has remained unchanged since the time of Muhammad? That belief is also largely based on hearsay.

As a Sikh, I thought you would be able to understand it. What ever happened to upholding the truth at all costs? I don't care if it hurts her feelings or she doesn't wanna hear it, it doesn't make it any less true. She is pushing her personal opinion, I am pushing the opinion of the vast...

This is nice and everything, but it is also anti-Islamic. Guru Nanak was not a Muslim, to place greater value in his words than those of the "authorities of Islam" is in itself enough to make you an unbeliever. Guru Nanak held many beliefs which were anti-Islamic, I strongly suggest you...

^^ The equivalent to shutting your eyes and covering your ears. Thank you for proving my point. Here's a suggestion: read the link, maybe you'll learn something from it. Please explain to me what is unscientific about the concept. Let me make myself clear: I think that Islam, while it...

Admin Ji, it was a rhetorical question, I do not expect a reply. I wanted her to reflect over it, I don't care if she answers back or not. I don't know how it works in Sikhism, but in Islam, scholars are of great importance and must be obeyed. And this is not from the hadith, this is from...

Are you sure you're reading the Qur'an? Doesn't sound like it :/ http://quran.com/search?q=Muslim Correctamundo! According to Islam, the people of the book ARE out of heaven. The Qur'an makes it very clear that the Jewish and Christian scriptures were, at one point, pure and true...

This is false, and is a position rejected by every Muslim I have ever interacted with, doesn't matter which sect they were from. You are the only person I know to have ever held this belief. This is rejected by 99%+ of Muslims in the world. The Qur'an says that anyone who obeys Allah and His...

I have a question. This pertains to one of my biggest problems with Islam. I am going to assume that the rest of your household is still Sikh. Please explain to me how you sleep at night holding the belief that your entire family will be burning in hell in the hereafter. The mother who gave...

I would agree, if someone had actually said that. In post #215, I was replying to Giyani Ji, who asked quite explicitly, "IF Mulsims can claim these are all "OURS"/OUR PROPHETS..even if they are JEWS..whats the problem with Farid Ji kabir Ji vis a vis SIKHS ?? I dont get it..." In other...