Paudi-4-Jap Ji Sahib Interpretation

Tejwant Singh · #55 (**permalink**) 22-Feb-2009, 12:42 PM

Quote:

VaheguruSeekr ji is translating ਅੰਮ੍ਰਿਤ ਵੇਲਾ as time when we do simran. Although time when we do simran is definitely ਅੰਮ੍ਰਿਤ.

Lali Hayer ji,

Guru Fateh.

I never said what you mentioned above. I have no idea why you are distorting what I said. It is sad to notice and bewildering why some people do that. To prove what?

What I said is the following and please respond it to it as I have asked Pk70 ji too.

"What does Amrit mean according to Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji and when it is not Vela -time for Amrit ? "

Let us be specific then only we can seek the truth not by accusing what has no been said. It does not lead us towards Shabad Vichaar, the word I used in my posts.

In the other tuks you have given, for me it does not mean early in the morning either. Rain drops have nothing to do with the morning because it can rain anytime of the day or night.

Having said that, if you understand it in a different way, it is ok with me. I have no problem with that. Just respond to the question based on Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji.

Thanks

Tejwant Singh

lalihayer · #56 (**permalink**) 22-Feb-2009, 13:04 PM

Vaheguruseekr ji asked,
I never said what you mentioned above. I have no idea why you are distorting what I said. It is sad to notice and bewildering why some people do that. To prove what?

Cut and paste from previous posts

Quote:

Post#42
There is a thread on this site in which Amarpal ji & I discussed this in details long time ago. Please look for it and I would request you to re post it. All the interpretators including the scholars who partipicate in here daily misinterpret what Guru Nanak said.

According Amarpal ji, and myself, anytime we have Shabad vichaar it is Amrit Vela.

Amrit Vela= The time for Amrit and what is Amrit... ? Amrit naam nidhaan hai, mil piyvoh Bhai.....

Post#50
What is Amrit and When it is NOT Amrit Vela according to Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, our only source.

So didn't you say that every vela when we do vichaar is amrit vela?
Aren't you trying to imply that amrit vela is not early morning but rather it is anytime when we do shabad vichar?

Tejwant Singh · #57 (**permalink**) 22-Feb-2009, 13:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by lalihayer

Vaheguruseekr ji asked,
I never said what you mentioned above. I have no idea why you are distorting what I said. It is sad to notice and bewildering why some people do that. To prove what?

Cut and paste from previous posts
So didn't you say that every vela when we do vichaar is amrit vela?
Aren't you trying to imply that amrit vela is not early morning but rather it is anytime when we do shabad vichar?

Lali hayer ji,

Guru Fateh.

You are again distorting things. I did not say Amrit Velas is NOT early in the morning.Yes, I did say that any time we do Shabad vichaar is Amrit Vela, which may include early in the morning,obviously, but not strictly early in the morning as you understand it..( I never used the word Simran which many claim is just repeating ). I did not say what you claimed in your post. Please re read what you wrote.

Now I am waiting for the response to my question.

Tejwant Singh