Why do Indian Vegetarians have a problem with Eggs but not with Milk?

Randip Singh · #91 (**permalink**) 10-Jul-2012, 18:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Searching

Gyani ji
There is no disputing what you have said. But there is difference in going to waste and waste product.
Urine and excreta are waste products produced by animals. Not egg.

Egg is a waste product, we've established that. Scroll up.

harry haller · #92 (**permalink**) 10-Jul-2012, 18:30 PM

Quote:

I don't think that is hypocritical since in Vaishnavism and other Hindu sects it is told that milk is sacred and you can drink it. Kinda like how in the gurdwara they have tablas with animal hide on it but still seems "ok" to us amritdhari Sikhs because it gives sound.

Kamalaji

are you Amritdhari?

Gyani Jarnail Singh · #93 (**permalink**) 10-Jul-2012, 18:57 PM

Ace Ventura.."pet detective"...is my favourite harry Ji....

Luckysingh · #94 (**permalink**) 11-Jul-2012, 10:19 AM

We can see by reading these 'unaccepting' attitudes, why we have this unnacepting problem among us.
For those of you that did NOT know that the egg is not fertilised and it was released as per cycle, regardless if there would be baby chicks or not.- Well, you must all have a better idea about where the egg comes from and how the milk is derived.- YET still there is this unaccepting attitude among some.
Reference:: Sikh Philosophy Network http://www.sikhphilosophy.net/health-and-nutrition/38699-why-do-indian-vegetarians-have-problem.html

Fact is - NO embryo, No future life is killed, egg is released naturally as part of biological mechanism, there is NO Pain and there is NO attachment of the egg to the mother, once it is released.
Reference:: Sikh Philosophy Network http://www.sikhphilosophy.net/showthread.php?t=38699

So, I can't understand why the 'unacceptables' are still having a problem accepting the difference between consuming milk or eggs!!

Gyani Jarnail Singh · #95 (**permalink**) 11-Jul-2012, 10:49 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Luckysingh

We can see by reading these 'unaccepting' attitudes, why we have this unnacepting problem among us.
For those of you that did NOT know that the egg is not fertilised and it was released as per cycle, regardless if there would be baby chicks or not.- Well, you must all have a better idea about where the egg comes from and how the milk is derived.- YET still there is this unaccepting attitude among some.

Fact is - NO embryo, No future life is killed, egg is released naturally as part of biological mechanism, there is NO Pain and there is NO attachment of the egg to the mother, once it is released.

So, I can't understand why the 'unacceptables' are still having a problem accepting the difference between consuming milk or eggs!!

Its called the "MAI NA MAANU" attitude...Simply put.." I DONT ACCEPT" PERIOD.

I juts wish that compared to the energy we put into "I DONT ACCEPT EGGS" into.."I DONT CONDONE KILLING FEMALE EMBRYOS"..endeavour..PUNJAB will soon see a drop in female foeticide...Bride Burning...Noohn murders, nooh tortures..harrassments wife beatings etc etc...THOSE are REAL Burning Issues and NOT piece of calcium encased egg emerging out of a hen's back. LOOKS like most Punjabis are more concerned with the alleged pain a Hen feels in its NATURAL FUNCTION than with the GROSS PAINS described above that most women go through...we have the priorities WRONG..winkingmunda