Dear Sahni Sahib and Archived_member2 Ji
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa
Waheguru Ji Ki fateh
S. Sahni Sahib
You have given an excellent explanation. But should one be professional Kirtania or Nishkam?
According to my views - Nishkam is only waheguru. You can see many people which are advertising Nishkam Kirtania but actually they r making money by other means like running charitable organisations!!!!!!!and cheating people under the Title of Niskamata and under the name of Charitable!!!!!!!!!
Taking money is bad or good if one is fully devotional towards
Guru Sahib?
And How much one Kirtania should take : I think as per Sharda of Sanagt and rules of Gurdwara Sahib or Sanagt inviting the Kirtania - No demand!!!!!!!should be there. The only demand should be that One should respect
Guru Sahib in all rspects!!!!!!!!!!!
Yes, Kirtania himself must listen to the
Kirtan, then only he can enjoy the grace of GOD!!!!
Sahni Sahib, u r giving excellent exlanation, please continue this.
Yes, S Archived_member2 ji , I am thankful to u too.
You have also given very good presentation to my questions!!
A S Saini