12-Apr-2009, 04:52 AM
|
 | | | | Enrolled: Feb 25th, 2008 Location: USA
Posts: 1,584
| |
Liked 616 Times in 317 Posts
| |  | |
| Re: Eh Janam Tumhare Lekhe
Quote:
Originally Posted by vsgrewal48895  I replied it and you never answered my question about the incomplete Sabd of Guru Arjan in Raag Ramkali, AGGS, Page 927.
Virinder | Respected VSGREWAL JI
Why I didn't answer? Very simple, I told you to obey Guru's Hukam on rituals instead of looking for more than two lines.
There could be just two lines and he never thought of adding to it.
How Bano-Bir carries authentic Shabad? you rely totally on Bano as per Harbans Singh, I dont because for me when Guru criticize rituals, there is no way the rituals were performed in Guru house. If they were, people would not stay with Guru because there were Dheermal and others shops were ready to take them. True Guru does what he practices. I am not going to accept Bano compared to Guru's own Shabadas against rituals period. I am sticking to Guru what he wrote about rituals not Bano and his so called Shabad.
Regards
G Singh
|