Originally Posted by jasleen_kaur

what is up with these kala afghana guys??? they're trying to turn sikhi into a judeo/christian/islamic thing...

yes, sikhi accepts the concepts of reincarnation and karma. for the writer to say that Guru Sahib wrote about something but didn't mean it is absolutely bizare. how could this guy know what Guru "really meant"? if Gurbani says we come and go in reincarnation until we find God, then that's what happens.
Gurbani says, "ape bij ape hi kahe" - what we sow, we reap. is there any clearer description of karma than that?

i just don't understand what this author is trying to achieve by undermining our core beliefs...