Sikhism - View Single Post

Archived_Member1 · #32 (**permalink**) 18-01-2008, 01:14 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by International Akaali

Jasleen kaur i think you fail to understand as to what gurbani is. Is Jaap sahib is considered gurbani then it would be included in Guru Granth sahib ji. As Guru Granth sahib ji is the only guru. Jaap sahib is a writing just like how zafarnama is. Its a piece of literature. It can never be considered gurbani. Gurbani is only that which is included in Guru Granth sahib ji.

ek bani ek gur eko shabad veechar

Here it is clear that guru sahib is only here in within in shri Guru Granth sahib ji. Can you say that guru sahib is contradicting himself. Guru sahib can never do such a thing therefore the shabad is only Guru Granth sahib ji. With this in mind please read the following shabad:

Bani Guru guru hai bani vich bani amrit sarai.

There is only ek bani. Ek Gur. Ek shabad veechar. Therefore there is only one gurbani which is shri Guru Granth sahib. Thus the writings of dasam granth can never be accepted as gurbani rather it can as literature for w.e the panth has said is authentic. jaap sahib is a piece of literature and anti-panthic forces mixed it in with the so called writings called "charitropakiyan" and others.

I will only take word for what is in roop of shabad guru, shri Guru Granth sahib ji if i am doing something in doing that i will continue to give mahan satkaar. Gurus bachan are posted above please follow your life according to the guru

Fateh

um, i'm pretty sure that "gurbani" means "word of Guru". that would be the word of ANY of the gurus. there were 10 living Gurus before the Guru Granth Sahib. 10 forms of Nanak. are you saying that their words became irrelevant when they passed on the gurgaddi? because that's what it sounds like.

i don't think i can find any shabads which support the theory that gurbani is only contained in SGGS. gurbani is only the word of the guru. but there's no restriction on WHICH guru.

as for you people's repeated purposeful misinterpretation of dasam granth, i'll just say, please research and understand the concepts of metaphor, analogy, and parable.