Sikhism - View Single Post

BhagatSingh · #31 (**permalink**) 18-01-2008, 01:11 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jasleen_kaur

interestingly, there was no controversy until nearly the 20th century. it has been suggested that agents of the british started the doubt about Sri Dasam Granth in order to weaken the Sikh Panth. in the past, SGGS was considered our spiritual guide, while SDGS was considered a temporal guide, and the key to our military strength. notice that Sikhs who still practice the martial arts (damdami taksal, nihangs, AKJ) all believe in it. so striking at the Dasam Granth strikes at our martial ability, making us more vulnerable to the british.

How does striking at the So called dasam granth strike at our martial ability??? how does reading make one a better warrior?? how does it make us more vulnerable to the british?? and why would we care??

well my dad doesn't practice martial arts at all and he believes in it. Although, he would never read it to my mom and sisters.

I don't know why... maybe...its because it's got porn in it! e.g. the raja in one of the stories takes out his "ling" and "bangs" the rani's "dhol"! haha!

that part always makes me laugh because of the language used.
In another one, this raja has two ranis, they dont get along. One rani has a child, the other one gets angry etc. She makes up a plan and shoves a "gophru", which is some kind of jewelry, up the child's bum. The rani who gave birth to the child dies, which makes the other rani (who shoved that thing up his ...) feels sorry, pulls out the gophru and starts taking care of the child.
Both of these stories are mentioned in this video:So called Dasam Granth or ****** Kavita
the guy argues that why would Guru Gobind write such a thing and even if he did what does this teach us??

Does this teach to shove things up people's bum? OR that we shouldn't do that because it might kill their mothers?? OR that we should bang dhol with ling?? pardon my language but what the ****?

dasam granth cannot be written by Guru Gobind Singh JI. Stop calling him the writer of this nonsensical piece of trash.
i agree there are some parts that do not go against Sikh philosophy, but even then most of it is agasint Sikhi!! On top of all this there is NO historical evidence that is written by Guru Gobind Singh Ji. Any historical evidence supporting this Granth can be questioned and easily ripped apart.
Dasam Granth