But i don't see why where having this argument because I agree that atheism and agnosticism cant be the same thing. Did you ever get around to watching that youtube video I posted? Becuase that essentially says the same thing... i mean, even in my original post i spent a great deal talkin about how atheist and agnostic are non-comparable terms. So im right there with you but i think your misreading the lable "agnostic-atheist" to mean "being both agnostic and atheist"