Quote:
Originally Posted by Kanwardeep Singh  Tejwant ji
Even 5ks are not in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji so should we start saying that there is no need of 5 ks.Also no where it is written in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji that Gurgaddi is pssed to Guru granth sahib,we have to rely on external sources for that.Please remember sikhism is Guru panth and guru granth sahib.Panth have to take many decisions to preserve sikhism.Without Panth there will no Guru granth sahib |
Kanwardeep Singh ji,
Guru Fateh.
I am bit puzzled by your post. My questions have nothing to do with what you said. Ofcourse, Sikhi is a unique way of life as compared to other religions. Our visionary Gurus did not write any history on purpose nor did they hire any artists to draw their portraits. Had they done both or either, then Sikhi would not be what it is today which is to shed Me-ism.
So, yes we have to rely on oral traditions and other parts of history written by others on hear says.
Yes, there is no place but in Rehatnaamas which claim that Guru Gobind Singh ji, gave Gurgadhi to Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. But, let us talk about the facts that we know. We know that Guru Arjan Dev ji compiled the Aad Granth and Guru Gobind Singh ji added his dad's Gurbani to it. So, there is no question that we are the true people of THE BOOK.
5k's are not a prerequisite to be a Sikh. That is the reason I said your post is a bit puzzling and has no relationship to what I asked Harbans ji.
Now, let us get to the slogan which you have used and it has been used quite frequently by many, especially after the case of Prof Sahib's episode.
Quote:
|
Without Panth there will no Guru granth sahib
|
Pardon my ignorance, but I have no idea what that means. Can you elaborate it with the verses from Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji so we can understand what Gurmat message is encrypted in it?
Panth was NOT started by Guru Gobind Singh ji but by Guru Nanak Dev Ji. The whole Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, our only Guru shows us what a Panthi is like and how one can become a Panthi.
In other words, the Sikhi panth cake was baked by our nine Gurus and Guru Gobind Singh put the icing on it.
If you would like to respond to my questions to Harbans ji, please feel free to pitch in.
Regards
Tejwant Singh