Quote:
Originally Posted by Narayanjot Kaur  Please focus, vikram9274 ji, on the question related to mantree bhoopat sambadh.
Is the above your answer to the question? "He may create a character" or "tell the story from the point of view of another?" Who could have done that? Are you saying that Guru Gobind Singh might have created a character? Or that Guru Gobind Singh might have told the story from the point of view of someone else? Or did someone else make up this mantree bhoopat sambadh affair?
Because if Guru Gobind Singh might have done it, well, someone else might have done it too!
I have not included the rest of your answer because you are wrong on the facts, do not understand the history of Dasam Granth, and are trying to dodge by talking about people who could have changed their minds but didn't as far as well know. |
Deletion for violations of TOS of Sikh Philosophy Network. Poster has been warned.
Directed at INTERNATION AKALI- Sir why should I beleive someone who says i see the light now? What made him see the light? After years of studying the Dasam Granth and doing Katha from it, within years it all changed? I just have a hard time believing that. He should come out and give his complete account of what made him change sides completely. And I am not arguing, I have already said that I think this issue is being blown out of proportion and I am only angry at the way it is being handled by both sides. I personally believe in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji and consider it to be my GURU but I also believe that the writing of Dasam Granth have substance and we can learn from them. I have no problem of Dasam Granth being prakashed next to Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. Those are my beliefs, my views, and my opinions. Simple as that. If you don't think Dasam Granth was written by Dasmesh Pitah or it has anything worth reading, then don't. If you don't want it prakashed next to the Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, well then don't do it if you have a copy of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji in your house. I just think that destroying the panth over the fact that two takhats keep the Dasam Granth Prakahsed next to the Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji is stupid because GURU JI wouldn't care and seeing as how Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji is supposed to be our GURU, I don't think it really matters. I don't have the time or the Gyan to argue lines or charitars of Dasam Granth. I am not a professor or historian. I think it is a beautiful piece of writing and holds many extremely useful lessons and a lot of information that one can use in life. So to me, it is worth reading and learning from.