Giani ji on dasam granth
http://www.sikhphilosophy.net/hard-t...han-singh.html
imho the entire drama is about the "Bachittar Natak"..Strange Drama !!
First Kala Afghana exposed this as fake and not written by Guru Gobind Singh Ji..
Then Prof Darshan Singh Ji Khalsaarshan Singh Ji also came forward to actively PROTEST this book being placed on Par with our GURU..
Thus those who "hate" kala Afghana must also hate Ragi....because they both are saying the same thing...Bachittar Natak aka dsm granth is NOT by Guru Ji and should NOT be parkash at Hazoor Sahib where the 3ooth Gurta Gadhi Diws of GURU is being celebrated..Gurta was given to ONLY
Guru Granth Sahib JI and no other boook/granth has nay equal significance especially at Hazoor Sahib where the 1708 decision by Guru Ji is being celebrated.
Source::
Sikh Philosophy Network
http://www.sikhphilosophy.net/showthread.php?t=23200 (Kala Afghana V/S Prof Darshan Singh Ji Khalsa)Reference:: Sikh Philosophy Network http://www.sikhphilosophy.net/general-discussion/25674-re-slander-dasam-granth-sikh-philosophy.html
Source::
Sikh Philosophy Network
http://www.sikhphilosophy.net/showthread.php?t=23200 (Kala Afghana V/S Prof Darshan Singh Ji Khalsa)
Thus it would be sweet music to these peopel...IF...the Ragi and KA were to fight !!
An enemy divided is an enemy dead....
BUT imho this is NOT about to happen any time soon....the KA wrote BOOKS..and the RAGI is an ORATOR...BOTH complement each other !!! Their MESSAGE is the SAME.."SAY NO TO DSM GRANTH".
Gyani Js
================================================== =============
You embrace Dasam Granth instead by undermining,disrepescting and second guessing Guru Gobind Singh ji. It needs nothing more than common sense to see that if Guru Gobind Singh ji wanted a granth by his name then he would not have added his father's Guru Teg Bahadur's Gurbani in Sri
Guru Granth Sahib Ji and hence would have rendered it useless.
It is appalling that you and your ilk do not accept Guru Gobind Singh's decision. So now you know that you and people who think the way you do are unshamedly heretic, which is sad.
================================================== ================
Giani ji on Dasam granth
Praising those who wrote against dasam granth and wee excommunicated
SO if..I say IF..a Bhag Singh Ambala came along and questioned the DSM Granth with ONE Book.....Bhai Gurbakhs Singh Kala Afghana came along and wrote TEN Books..many others also wrote not only BOOKS but also offered a REWARD of TEN LAKH Rupees to anyoen who cna prove that the writer of dsm Granth is Guru Gobind Singh Ji....SO WHAT ?? IF these people are all FRAUDS..telling lies..have no basis..what are we AFRAID OF ?? Why go to extrereme knee jerk reactions like excommunicate them, villify them, take a microscope and digg durt on their personal lives to discredit them....and form so called Human Rights Organsiations that DECIDE on DSm Granth ( Human Rights !! not Scripture Rights ??) set up Orgs and Coms and Nets on the Internet etc etc to "prove" something that NEEDS NO PROOF ?? Why not let the FALSEHOOD FALL ON ITS OWN ??
================================================== ==========
Again Giani ji calls rehatnamsa and hukam nama as fake'
Fake Laetters of Bhai mani Singh..Fake rehitnamahs, Hukmanmahs, etc etc and all...has been going on for CENTURIES...
people all over can read the TRUTH..in
www.Rozana spokesman.com
================================================== ===============
Tejwant calling others Hindus for respecting DG
Inder Singh ji,
I want to thank you for showing your true colors and your faith in Hinduism which is not a bad thing. Lots of Hindus are also members of this
Sikh forum.
================================================== =============
Tejwant calling believers in dasam bani as Hindutva
When these things about DG being the work of Guru Gobind Singh keep on cropping up by some whose agenda is nothing but deviate us from our only GURU- Sri
Guru Granth Sahib Ji and add Hindutva into Sikhi.
Reference:: Sikh Philosophy Network http://www.sikhphilosophy.net/showthread.php?t=25674
================================================== =========
Khalsa fauj on dasam granth
I am a
Sikh of
Guru Granth Sahib Ji. You can bring your Guru which is Dasam Granth, to live debate. We can read some chariters to the sangat.
NOTE Same thread for these